Your argument is one of extremes. The relevant consideration is what occurs on the margins. There are some rich people who have decided not to take their capital elsewhere, but will if they are taxed more. Your premise is that these people don't exist and that is not true.
Re:What does one trillion dollars look like?
by nazgulnarsil on Wednesday March 11, 2009 @10:04AM
(#511748)
it's not about large quantities of money just sitting in a bank account. it's about investment. high taxes discourage reinvestment of profits back into businesses.
Re:What does one trillion dollars look like?
by forinti on Wednesday March 11, 2009 @12:29PM
(#511964)
Only indirectly. If a business can profit more from investing than it can from sitting the money in the bank, then it will regardless of the taxes. Higher taxes will lower consumption and raise costs, but they won't deter investment by themselves, otherwise nobody would start businesses in Sweden or Belgium.
Re:What does one trillion dollars look like?
by nazgulnarsil on Wednesday March 11, 2009 @03:21PM
(#512310)
right, taxes are just changing the equilibrium point.
Additionally, so what if the top few % take their capital away elsewhere? There are millions of entrepreneurs who can fill their space. These "rich will leave and you will suffer" tactics make sense if they aren't already investing elsewhere heavily and if the rest of the world is a much better investment opportunity than the US. But that isn't so and hasn't been so in a long time.
I'm not saying tax the rich unfairly. I'm just saying I don't buy the "if you tax the rich they will leave" line anymore because that line only works in an untapped free market for capital with perfect competition, which we do not have anywhere in the world.