News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by rauljara on Friday January 25, 2013 @11:21AM (#5116123)
So apparently Apple is making good on its promise to look deeper down in the supply chain. While it sucks for the workers at the plant that they're probably going to lose their jobs (shitty work is [usually] better than no work), the jobs aren't actually going away. They're just being shifted to another factory that now has the knowledge that they too could be fired for what Westerners consider egregious working conditions.

This is great, and the outcome of putting a lot of vocal and consistent pressure on Apple to behave in a less inhumane fashion. It's yet another example that well organized and vocal campaigns can result in meaningful change. They do take a while, though.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by stevenbedrick on Friday January 25, 2013 @02:20PM (#5117129)
> While it sucks for the workers at the plant that they're probably going to lose their jobs...

From TFA:

    When new violations are found, Apple requires its suppliers to return the workers back to a school chosen by the family and finance their education. "In addition, the children must continue to receive income matching what they received when they were employed. We also follow up regularly to ensure that the children remain in school and that the suppliers continue to uphold their financial commitment," wrote Apple in its latest report.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by jlgreco on Friday January 25, 2013 @02:36PM (#5117211)
I don't understand how Apple could do that if they completely fired the company. If they are still doing business with them then they could make such demands, but if they outright sacked the company why would that company continue to do what Apple tells them to?

Is the local government providing enforcement?

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by MaysonL on Saturday January 26, 2013 @01:37AM (#5119522)
That requirement was for the multiple contractors whom they found had unintentionally rather than deliberately hired underage workers, and was a condition of retaining Apple business. This was in addition to required training in how to avoid hiring underage workers, and establishing procedures to avoid this.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by UnFleshedOne on Friday January 25, 2013 @04:44PM (#5117842)
Looks like that applies to _new_ violations, with new contractors and new contracts I assume.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by rscale on Friday January 25, 2013 @02:38PM (#5117218)
A contract clause withholding outstanding payments until certain conditions are met would do the trick.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by jlgreco on Friday January 25, 2013 @02:49PM (#5117264)
I suppose such a contract would work provided the cost of fulfilling those obligations did not exceed the outstanding payment. Otherwise I would expect the company to just cut their loses.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by Someone on Friday January 25, 2013 @03:57PM (#5117585)
It may not be perfect (which country's is?), but China has a justice system. A court case with Apple's weight (and money) behind it probably would be reasonably succesful in China.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by jlgreco on Friday January 25, 2013 @06:54PM (#5118494)
Yeah, local government enforcement is the most likely way I can see this being effectively enforced.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by Gorbzel on Saturday January 26, 2013 @01:56AM (#5119563)
Wait...what? The outcome of vocal pressure on Apple to change? There were definitely people pushing for better visibility of the human costs of the electronics industry, but aren't we being a bit circle jerky here? Well-orgaznied and vocal campaigns? I don't know what you're talking about, but suffice it to say I'm not sure this can't be mostly attributed to Tim Cook's increased focus on supply chain and manufacturing and the human consequences thereof.

Ultimately, there's clearly a net positive here: less violations of clear human rights concerns in Chinese factories. I think everyone can agree, that's a good thing. But I can't help but be worried about this notion that this is some massive "win" for a campaign pressuring Apple. This is a problem with the entire industry, and one that needs to be solved. Maybe it's a symptom of being the world's largest company, but too many hugely critical issues to geekdom (patent reform, the costs of cheap mfr labor, etc) get oversimplified in comments like the above into some postured for / against Apple and completely miss the point. It's intellectually cheap and really just getting old and preventing a lot of real good work from getting done...

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by Volpe on Saturday January 26, 2013 @07:07AM (#5120154)
I don't think it's a win. These underage workers likely weren't doing it against their will. So really we just fired a bunch of poor people, because we think they are too young to work... Win!

Do we really think these underage workers are going to go home and play Xbox, or go to school?

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by VMG on Friday January 25, 2013 @11:48AM (#5116317)
> While it sucks for the workers at the plant [..]

> This is great [..]

Aren't these statements contradictory? Isn't the supposed goal to help underage workers?

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by gtr32x on Friday January 25, 2013 @01:22PM (#5116821)
First I would like to say I am not in support of underage workers, I would never be. However, if we look at the realistic situations in certain parts of the globe, especially China, sometimes it is not always such a simple situation that we allow these underage workers to work.

In some far far away frugal rural land, a family is struggling financially. Their 14 year old son was not able to go to school, neither was there enough food to be fed to him. The news hit that there's a plant that's openly hiring workers without age restriction. The seemingly insignificant pay in the western's eyes will be a huge help to the family's financial in the remote rural China. After all, it's much better to work at such places than some coal mine that severely underpays.

Depending on where you are born from, some kids are meant to grow up faster than others. Some kids just cannot afford a normal education like everybody else should. It's not a fair world and it never will be. Is it fair for the kids? No it's not, but what's their best option?

Of course, not all situations are like this, but for situations where underage workers are actually working, there is a strong trend that this may possibly be the case. After all, who in the right mind would send their child to work at such an early age is they don't have to? Who doesn't want to live a good life? Remember Li Ka-Ching? He started working at a young age of 15 at a watch shop. See where he is at today?

Once again, I am not saying that education isn't important, I believe it is. However, under so many unique circumstances, it isn't always the most viable path one goes through.

I don't support underage workers, this comment isn't meant to bring to justice to the underage worker hiring practices in China. But it just pains me to see people generalize that the goal is to 'help' underage workers. The situation isn't the same in the West, hence why we think like that. It's a well wish and a prospect to help the country though.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by jjoonathan on Friday January 25, 2013 @03:07PM (#5117344)
If you draw a box around labour and management and compute the relative bargaining power of each group, child labour worsens the bargaining position of labour (by increasing supply). It is in the collective interests of China's poor (children and adults alike) to see child labour ended.

What you have noticed is something completely different: it may be advantageous for an individual family to send their child to work.

Restrictions on child labour put the system out of Nash equilibrium but they perform better globally with respect to helping the poor. This paradox manifests itself in many places; I suspect, given that this is Hacker News, that you may be familiar with a few of them already.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braess%27s_paradox

The critical conclusion that free markets search for nash equilibria but NOT global optima is highly relevant to fiscal philosophy and entrepreneurship.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by VMG on Friday January 25, 2013 @02:11PM (#5117086)
Then let me say that I am in support of underage workers.

The idea that preventing children to work in these factories helps the children is ill-conceived, as you pointed out. If Apple wanted to help these children, it could have required better working conditions or better pay, but not letting them work doesn't achieve the goal.

These kids won't just say "alright let's go to school then" when they can't work anymore.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by yarianluis on Friday January 25, 2013 @02:51PM (#5117279)
Not in the case of firing the company outright but the article clearly illustrates what happens to the children these companies employ against contract terms:

>Apple requires its suppliers to return the workers back to a school chosen by the family and finance their education. "In addition, the children must continue to receive income matching what they received when they were employed. We also follow up regularly to ensure that the children remain in school and that the suppliers continue to uphold their financial commitment," wrote Apple in its latest report.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by VMG on Friday January 25, 2013 @03:38PM (#5117502)
Tough luck for those children who didn't already work there.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by mc32 on Friday January 25, 2013 @02:41PM (#5117231)
^This sums up the situation pretty well.

Trying to do good does have unintended consequences. If pressure works, it will mean that underage workers will have one fewer avenue towards self-sustenance, or ability to help their destitute families. If I were underage I would want the option to work at a factory rather than combing the garbage dumps ofr scraps --at least there is a future on a factory floor, for the time being.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by abraininavat on Friday January 25, 2013 @03:15PM (#5117375)
By definition any company hiring children in China is doing it illegally. By definition any company hiring children in China and working for Apple is doing it (one hopes) in secret and without Apple's consent. Given those two premises, it's not hard to extrapolate that said company is unlikely to place a high priority on avoiding inhumane treatment of said children.

Child labor and humane treatment of workers do not go hand in hand. After all, if you are paying fair wages and have good working conditions, why would you choose to hire children instead of adults?

> After all, who in the right mind would send their child to work at such an early age is they don't have to?

Many people. You don't think any child is working because her parents ignorantly don't see any value in an education? Your view that parents are universally well-intentioned and know how to make the right choices for their children is as naive as the view that no child would be better off working than going to school. Unless you think China has the capacity to inspect every home to make an individual determination of a child's right to work, I think most of us prefer it be universally banned than universally allowed.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by VMG on Friday January 25, 2013 @03:48PM (#5117542)
This isn't about a general ban of child labor but about removing one option for children to work. One could try to argue for a general ban, but that is a different issue.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by abraininavat on Friday January 25, 2013 @03:51PM (#5117562)
What? Child labor is already generally banned in China. I just argued that giving money to a company that is secretly, illegally partaking in child labor is giving money (and therefore encouragement) to a company that is likely engaging in inhumane labor practices.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by SoftwareMaven on Friday January 25, 2013 @11:51AM (#5116351)
Getting vaccinated sucks because you have to get poked, but it's great when you don't get the flu. It's possible to suck today but lead to a better state of being.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by e1ven on Friday January 25, 2013 @11:49AM (#5116328)
Presumably, not all the workers are the plant are underage. Having compassion for those who are losing their jobs is rather human.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by awestroke on Friday January 25, 2013 @11:52AM (#5116353)
Short term vs long term
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by VMG on Friday January 25, 2013 @11:56AM (#5116378)
In the long term, underage workers still can't work there and have to work somewhere else, presumably somewhere where they wouldn't work if they had the choice.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by ChuckMcM on Friday January 25, 2013 @01:20PM (#5116809)
Technically in the long term the workers will age and become age appropriate and enter the workforce legally with an advantage of prior experience. Although its a fair point that there are other places, undoubtedly with less oversight where these children might be shipped off too.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by bilbo0s on Friday January 25, 2013 @11:43AM (#5116292)
The unfortunate reality of global business is that those components will simply end up in other devices. The companies which sell the devices will just try harder to hide it from the consumer.

The pressure needs to be put not so much on Apple, as on the industry... or the practices continue pretty much unabated.

Unless Apple really does turn into a monopoly.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by SoftwareMaven on Friday January 25, 2013 @11:50AM (#5116338)
Since consumers have no visibility into the problem nor ability to solve the problem, I disagree that it starts with them (but it needs to get to them eventually).

Apple wields a very large, very concentrated number of dollars, which may be enough to get the ball rolling. Other higher-end electronics companies may decide that, for marketing reasons, they will only work with "Apple approved" vendors or may decide the positive press is worth approving their own.

It will be some time before the fifty-cent, crap electronics are reached, but you have to start somewhere.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by sp332 on Friday January 25, 2013 @12:21PM (#5116513)
Jobs will not move to other factories, because the underage workers are still underage.