Re:Should children have the right to vote?
by tptacek on Wednesday March 11, 2009 @09:20AM
(#511691)
Your logic doesn't work. There is no similarity between "protecting women" and "protecting children". Women don't need to be protected. Children obviously do, at least from some things.
Re:Should children have the right to vote?
by DavidSJ on Wednesday March 11, 2009 @12:18PM
(#511949)
You misunderstand me. I was not, in that comment, stating that women and children should be protected (or not) from the same things.
I was pointing out, simply, that (whether right or wrong), being "protected" from politics is in fact protection from oneself.
Now, you may feel that children should be protected from themselves, whereas women should not. That is a perfectly consistent position. The grandparent seemed to be unclear that that is what you were advocating, and that is the confusion I was clearing up.
Put another way: you're trying to deny them the opportunity to make a certain choice (that is, vote) for their own good. That is the definition of protecting someone from them-self.