Honestly, I agree with you. When I submitted the story to HN the title was "First unsigned artist in modern history to hit #1 on U.S. Charts" but HN changed it to the title on the blog. I wanted to highlight why I was posting it in the first place. Race can play an important part of a story but this time it kind of takes the focus off of the important part.
Re:How an unsigned rapper changed music
by charliepark on Thursday January 24, 2013 @11:53AM
(#5110529)
This isn't the first time an HN editor's change has made a post's title less relevant to the HN readership[1].
I'm really tired of it, but since it's all done behind the scenes, I don't know how to productively comment on it or suggest that they stop doing it.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4994745 (and that link's parent: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4993953)
Re:How an unsigned rapper changed music
by smallegan on Thursday January 24, 2013 @12:45PM
(#5110881)
If it is the title of the article how does that make it less relevant?
Re:How an unsigned rapper changed music
by rjsamson on Thursday January 24, 2013 @01:15PM
(#5111093)
I think at times a different title may serve as a way for the poster to convey some relevant and appropriate commentary on why it is being posted.
Re:How an unsigned rapper changed music
by samstave on Thursday January 24, 2013 @09:54PM
(#5113687)
Exactly!
Only pedants don't understand this.
Re:How an unsigned rapper changed music
by jessedhillon on Thursday January 24, 2013 @12:28PM
(#5110784)
Pointing out that he's white is a nod to his status as a dark horse. He is one of the least likely people to disrupt this genre/industry through success. Simply by looking at the statistics of who becomes successful, chart-topping rappers, we can see that it's very unlikely for a white guy to be successful at this level.
Re:How an unsigned rapper changed music
by halvsjur on Thursday January 24, 2013 @01:25PM
(#5111160)
Regarding color, I think you're at least a decade late. Eminem released The Slim Shady LP in 1999. Then you got Beastie Boys, Aesop Rock, El-P, Atmosphere, etc.
Let's not forget 3rd Bass, Cypress Hill, House of Pain, etc. White rappers have been around forever; to act like they're some sort of new or even remotely rare phenomenon is kind of silly at this point.
By 1999 Beastie Boys had 5 LPs under their belt
Re:How an unsigned rapper changed music
by halvsjur on Thursday January 24, 2013 @02:14PM
(#5111488)
Yeah, Beastie Boys are huge, but Eminem is a superstar.
Re:How an unsigned rapper changed music
by jessedhillon on Thursday January 24, 2013 @02:20PM
(#5111526)
I'm just pointing out what the perception might be which caused the author to pick that headline. Plus, really you can only pick a handful of successful white rappers, for the level of success we're talking about here. Black rappers are far and away the majority.
Re:How an unsigned rapper changed music
by InclinedPlane on Thursday January 24, 2013 @06:22PM
(#5112910)
White rappers aren't exactly some crazy, new phenomenon. Vanilla Ice, Eminem, Everlast, The Beastie Boys, MC Frontalot, etc, several of them have been hugely popular. I don't think mentioning race is useful.
When I saw the headline I guessed Macklemore so from an information theoretic sense it helped me out. Although I'm a face recognition researcher who has written ethnicity detectors so maybe I'm biased.
Probably because of Jay-Z start of his career selling CDs from his car and then making Roc-a-fella?
I'd say because it's even more difficult for a white rapper to make it big in the industry. It's one more hurdle they had to overcome.
I don't think this was ever the case for white rappers.
Re:How an unsigned rapper changed music
by MisterBastahrd on Thursday January 24, 2013 @09:34PM
(#5113603)
Especially because of the content of his music, some of which is extremely progressive for the genre.
I get that "white" rappers for the hip-hop ignorant are somewhat of a novelty but come on ... linkbait headline at it's worst IMHO.