Re:Responsive: A Task for the Developer or the Device?
by quarterto on Thursday January 24, 2013 @01:41PM
(#5111250)
Form factors, no. Screen sizes is reasonable.
p.s. didn't notice this until just now because it wasn't a reply to my comment and so didn't show up on http://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=quarterto
Re:Responsive: A Task for the Developer or the Device?
by hello-yoshi on Thursday January 24, 2013 @02:26PM
(#5111570)
My bad on the reply (or lack thereof). I agree to date responsive gives a generally better experience for most sites. I don't think however it's the best solution for mobile design.
It compromises usability through a changing of the interface, there is no reduced markup size and it's a very costly endeavour.
Re:Responsive: A Task for the Developer or the Device?
by jordanmoore_ on Friday January 25, 2013 @04:24AM
(#5114694)
Bad responsive design compromises usability - good responsive design applies itself to the context and enhances usability.
@quarterto, agreed you can't expect a device to completely decipher all forms of content but you can ask it to do much better. You also can't expect a developer to deliver for all form factors.
@rnassar, agreed on the alternative forms of consumption. We can probably move more of that into the devices natively.