Re:Andrew Auernheimer case uncomfortably similar to Aaron Sw...
by anigbrowl on Thursday January 24, 2013 @02:01AM
(#5108089)
Especially where defendants are characteristically individuals without the resources to defend their interpretation of the law in court.
Not true. Just because you may have to rely on a public defender doesn't mean your legal theory would have legs with a better lawyer.
A kid who sneaks through your literal open window and starts nosing around in your house is not pointing out a critical security vulnerability; you know that your window is open. There is no benefit to the homeowner, the kid is just a pest. But computers have higher security requirements: The equivalent of an open window is a major failing in need of immediate attention, because if a kid can get in then so can foreign criminal syndicates, and if they get in they'll be doing more than poking around.
That's true as a pragmatic matter, but it is not your decision to make about other people's systems. I can think of cases where an open window is a critical security vulnerability; kids can fall out of them, medical or legal papers may be accessible to third parties and put the subject of those papers in jeopardy and so on. But that doesn't entitle me to climb through the window in order to demonstrate or draw the homeowner's or business operator's attention to the risks of the open window.
While it's quite true that AT&T was doing its customers a disservice here, and I have no problem with people observing and commenting upon that fact, it's their computer system, not yours. You don't have a right to poke around there just because you have the know-how to build/operate a more secure system. I doubt you would appreciate a private security company representative turning up in your living room to harangue you about your open window. You would rightly tell him that a) it's not his business and b) if he wants to help, ring the fucking doorbell first, rather than publishing an directory of what's inside your house.
Not true. Just because you may have to rely on a public defender doesn't mean your legal theory would have legs with a better lawyer.
A kid who sneaks through your literal open window and starts nosing around in your house is not pointing out a critical security vulnerability; you know that your window is open. There is no benefit to the homeowner, the kid is just a pest. But computers have higher security requirements: The equivalent of an open window is a major failing in need of immediate attention, because if a kid can get in then so can foreign criminal syndicates, and if they get in they'll be doing more than poking around.
That's true as a pragmatic matter, but it is not your decision to make about other people's systems. I can think of cases where an open window is a critical security vulnerability; kids can fall out of them, medical or legal papers may be accessible to third parties and put the subject of those papers in jeopardy and so on. But that doesn't entitle me to climb through the window in order to demonstrate or draw the homeowner's or business operator's attention to the risks of the open window.
While it's quite true that AT&T was doing its customers a disservice here, and I have no problem with people observing and commenting upon that fact, it's their computer system, not yours. You don't have a right to poke around there just because you have the know-how to build/operate a more secure system. I doubt you would appreciate a private security company representative turning up in your living room to harangue you about your open window. You would rightly tell him that a) it's not his business and b) if he wants to help, ring the fucking doorbell first, rather than publishing an directory of what's inside your house.