News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I'm sorry by jballanc on Thursday January 24, 2013 @01:47AM (#5108024)
You know what would be better than a blog post or Twitter apology? Go away for a little while. Don't Tweet. Don't Blog. Don't comment or talk. Go away...and code.

The programmer community likes to fancy itself a meritocracy. Presumably, that implies that you are judged on the merit of your programming ability. Ask yourself: of the people involved in this whole brouhaha, whose code have you read?

We are all very busy, and none among us has the time to read the code of every other individual. This is where the concept of "meritocracy" breaks down. At some point, reputations count. The proper way to do this is: I know Joe. Joe writes good code. Joe recommends Bob's code, and when I looked at Bob's code, it was also good. I now trust Joe when he recommends people and/or their code.

The wrong way to do this is: Jim's a celebrity. Everybody loves him. Everybody parrots what he says. He must write good code.

Celebrity culture is directly counter to a meritocracy. So, my challenge to the "celebrities" involved in this incident: if you fancy your high positions to be well and truly earned, remind us of that fact by going away...

...and writing some kick-ass code.

Re:I'm sorry by benburton on Thursday January 24, 2013 @07:06AM (#5109096)
> Ask yourself: of the people involved in this whole brouhaha, whose code have you read?

I've definitely read Steve Klabnik's code. He's a Rails core team member, and when I work on a Rails app I frequently open stuff up to see what's going on under the hood.

> Celebrity culture is directly counter to a meritocracy. So, my challenge to the "celebrities" involved in this incident: if you fancy your high positions to be well and truly earned, remind us of that fact by going away and writing some kick-ass code.

I know that Steve's always writing code for one public open source thing or another... I've seen it. He also happens to tweet a lot. I don't think that the two things you're suggesting here have to be mutually exclusive.

Re:I'm sorry by jballanc on Thursday January 24, 2013 @09:26AM (#5109631)
I don't think I said they have to be mutually exclusive. But part of the problem, as outlined in the original post, is that these weren't anybodys disparaging an open source project...they were veritable celebrities! (Just look at their follower count!)

At the same time, Steve (as he stated in his post), seems to be having a hard time expressing his remorse. My suggestion is that he should remember why he ever attained "celebrity" status in the first place...

...also, it's a lot harder to disparage other people's code when you're buried deep in your own code.

Edit: I lost track of whose post was whose and originally wrote "as he stated in this post". Corrected.

Re:I'm sorry by Confusion on Thursday January 24, 2013 @05:04AM (#5108713)

  Ask yourself: of the people involved in this whole 
  brouhaha, whose code have you read?
Of most of them. It seems you are unaware who these people are and what projects they have contributed to. You're making a good point, but these are the wrong people to use as an example for that point.
Re:I'm sorry by jballanc on Thursday January 24, 2013 @05:47AM (#5108853)
The point is not that no one has read the "celebrities" code. The point is that if you looked at the ratio of "people who have heard of <person>" to "people who have read the code produced by <person>" for the people involved, I suspect there would be one outlier.

(as a simple post-script...I am very aware of these people and their projects, and made this comment in that context...)

Re:I'm sorry by recursive on Thursday January 24, 2013 @09:04AM (#5109521)
I have never heard of anyone involved. But at this point I would count that as a win.
Re:I'm sorry by Tichy on Thursday January 24, 2013 @06:31AM (#5108990)
People said something they regret, I don't understand why it would be wrong to apologize? Sorry, can't follow the logic of your comment at all?
Re:I'm sorry by jballanc on Thursday January 24, 2013 @09:55AM (#5109780)
You should re-read what I wrote. I did not say apologizing would be wrong. I expressed my opinion on what would be an even better course of action.
Re:I'm sorry by Tichy on Friday January 25, 2013 @08:13AM (#5115207)
Yeah but I don't get it. How would ignoring the issue be a better apology? These people write code anyway, there is no way the victim could realize "ah, they are silently writing code, so they must be sorry". And the people following their example also wouldn't have that thought.
Re:I'm sorry by __cle on Sunday January 27, 2013 @07:32PM (#5126397)
The apology should have been a direct one, to her, outside the public lime (and lemon) light.
Re:I'm sorry by Tichy on Tuesday January 29, 2013 @09:34AM (#5134135)
I still don't see why a public apology is wrong, especially if the offending party is popular and sets an example for others.