Re:Andrew Auernheimer case uncomfortably similar to Aaron Sw...
by tptacek on Thursday January 24, 2013 @12:40AM
(#5107679)
They can and do get consent before looking for vulnerabilities.
The idea that security researchers are or even should be free to poke at random websites for vulnerabilities so they can "inform the public" is a myth. It's a meme that's seen most of its spread over the last few years. A couple years ago, most professional researchers would warn you not to test public web applications for flaws. People have gotten into serious legal trouble for doing that.
The C.W. on this has obviously changed. But I don't think the law has!
The best web application shops post pages, like 37signals, or Github, or Google, inviting researchers and instructing them how to report their findings. If you're concerned that you might be using an application that would sue or press charges for someone conducting unauthorized security tests, just stick to the ones that have security pages.
The web applications that don't post pages like this? Don't poke them. It's illegal and (you'd know better than me, Rayiner) probably a tort, which means you can get sued for it right through your corporate liability protection.
The idea that security researchers are or even should be free to poke at random websites for vulnerabilities so they can "inform the public" is a myth. It's a meme that's seen most of its spread over the last few years. A couple years ago, most professional researchers would warn you not to test public web applications for flaws. People have gotten into serious legal trouble for doing that.
The C.W. on this has obviously changed. But I don't think the law has!
The best web application shops post pages, like 37signals, or Github, or Google, inviting researchers and instructing them how to report their findings. If you're concerned that you might be using an application that would sue or press charges for someone conducting unauthorized security tests, just stick to the ones that have security pages.
The web applications that don't post pages like this? Don't poke them. It's illegal and (you'd know better than me, Rayiner) probably a tort, which means you can get sued for it right through your corporate liability protection.