News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Web Directory Of Attorneys Upsets D.C. Bar by gills on Tuesday March 10, 2009 @04:58PM (#510641)
I based my snarky remark on this from the article:

"Avvo.com, the site posting the profiles, says it's simply using public data to help consumers find lawyers and their track records.

"There's no reason why lawyer-licensing records should be treated any differently than records for any other profession," said Joshua King, general counsel for the Seattle start-up. "The bar doesn't like the fact that the information is out of its control." "

Re:Web Directory Of Attorneys Upsets D.C. Bar by iamwil on Tuesday March 10, 2009 @05:09PM (#510672)
Right, so I don't understand brandnewlow's stance. If Avvo is using public data, since when does anyone get to lay claim on public data?

Sounds to me that they're more upset about potentially being mis-rated, rather than the information itself. If the rates gave them more clients across the board instead of the negative reviews, I doubt they'd be complaining.

Re:Web Directory Of Attorneys Upsets D.C. Bar by antiismist on Tuesday March 10, 2009 @05:57PM (#510779)
FWIW I find avvo to be pretty sleazy. I am a lawyer but haven't ever practiced law nor do I intend to. Nonetheless, avvo has created a profile for me that lists out my personal info (name, address, phone number, graduate school, undergrad), lets people review me, and spams me to get me to claim my profile.

I think it's one of those things that sounds great theoretically but isn't so great when it happens to you. Not saying that I am going to sue, but I find it in pretty poor form.

Re:Web Directory Of Attorneys Upsets D.C. Bar by iamwil on Tuesday March 10, 2009 @11:17PM (#511218)
I'm not in the law profession, but is that (name, address, phone, etc) public information? I can imagine personal info being disconcerting.

While I've never visited Avvo's site, according to the article, there are other pieces of information there. What about the history of which cases a lawyer has won or lost? Is that public info? What about ratings and comments generated by past clients on a public website? It seemed to me the bar was miffed about that too, even though I've venture to say that's for all intents and purposes, public.

Other than your name, and perhaps where you attended law school, I'd agree that personal info shouldn't be on there. But I don't think use of public info is unfair.

I'm not sure the public rating of lawyers in the form they implemented to be the best way or even a good way of finding and evaluating lawyers. But I don't think it's bad to try or use public information to do so.

Re:Web Directory Of Attorneys Upsets D.C. Bar by antiismist on Wednesday March 11, 2009 @11:34AM (#511872)
I understand how the information is public and therefore free to use. All I'm saying is that it sounds great in theory, until someone goes ahead and makes your profile and gathers up your personal info and lets people rate you. I didn't ask for it explicitly or implicitly so it is annoying.
Re:Web Directory Of Attorneys Upsets D.C. Bar by brandnewlow on Tuesday March 10, 2009 @05:11PM (#510676)
Paragraph 4 has the lawyer for the DC folks saying they're misusing their data. I was alluding to her stance in a way I thought was colorful.