News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It’s time all clinical trial results are reported by kyro on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @03:49PM (#5099477)
Yes, yes, yes, yes.

Signed and donated.

This is a great effort, and I suggest others help out as well. The amount of fake trials and hidden experiment data that pharmas participate in is absurd. I can't recall the exact incident ('carbocation probably will) but within the last decade there was a rather large scandal where a particular drug was known to have a fatal side effect -- suicidal ideation, I believe [wrong, valvular heart damage - see below] -- and more than 90% of the trial data that pointed to said effect was hidden and concealed. The drug hit the market and was later pulled off the shelves because, you guessed it, people started dying! While I don't believe the reporting of all trials will fix that level of deceit, it's certainly a great step in the right direction. Pushing for public reporting of data concerning meds that people might eventually put into their bodies only makes sense.

Next up: Abolishing sponsored research clinical trials, or at least increasing the transparency of research sponsorship instead of burying the fact that the research PI is actually an employee of Pfizer somewhere deep in the appendices.

It's amazing how we have organizations like Consumer Reports to give us objective reviews of toasters and cars, yet nothing like that exists for medications or medical devices, isn't it?

Edit: So I'm confusing 2 things:

1) Fen-phen was a diet pill pushed to market despite evidence that it caused valvular heart damage. It was pulled from the market. Read: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/prescription/h...

2) SSRIs were the drugs that increase suicidality (something commonly known now) and the data confirming that was reportedly hidden by pharmas. Read: http://reason.com/archives/2007/07/10/can-caution-be-too-ris...

Re:It’s time all clinical trial results are reported by carbocation on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @04:49PM (#5099827)
Good examples. I'll add Vioxx (rofecoxib), a Merck COX-2-specific NSAID that was released in 1999 and pulled in 2004 [1]. Merck hid evidence that the drug caused cardiovascular events and death. Eventually, the evidence became impossible to suppress [2]. Meta-analyses demonstrated that, given the ongoing trials at the time, Merck could have (and almost certainly did) observe internally that there was an excess of cardiovascular mortality in the Vioxx arm of their (combined) trials [3]. Eventually, the drug was removed from the market, but not before what has been estimated as nearly 100 thousand attributable heart attacks [4].

[1] = http://www.fda.gov/Drugs/DrugSafety/PostmarketDrugSafetyInfo...

[2] = http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/medical_exa...

[3] = http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-67...

[4] = http://www.consumersunion.org/pub/core_health_care/001651.ht...

Re:It’s time all clinical trial results are reported by EvanKelly on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @05:22PM (#5099999)
I read your second article on SSRIs and I'm confused at the point you're trying to make. The article (written in 2007) concludes that an over-reaction to the British journal's reports that SSRIs increase suicidal ideation (ergo suicide) may have actually caused more suicides due to under-prescription of SSRIs in adolescents.

The article cites many university studies which show that use of SSRIs actually coincided with a decreased risk of suicidal ideation.

Is there more recent evidence to suggest the British studies were correct?

I hear a lot of anecdotal evidence when SSRIs and other anti-depressants are discussed, which I agree is important because everyone can react differently to them and doctors and patients should be aware of what may occur, but the article you linked to actually states that the clinical evidence is in support of SSRI prescription in all age groups with major depression.

EDIT: I do note that the article mentions the GSK settlement with Spitzer, and regardless of whether the studies hold true, they should not have been covered up unless there was a question to the scientific standards of the trials.

Re:It’s time all clinical trial results are reported by refurb on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @06:29PM (#5100325)
Abolish sponsored clinical trials? How do you plan to fund them then?

A very large part of the multi-billion dollar a year R&D budgets of the pharmaceutical companies go to pay for clinical trials. How would you replace that money?

Re:It’s time all clinical trial results are reported by justsee on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @06:33PM (#5100349)
Simple really. Establish an independent entity to conduct them, and fund those activities as part of the approval process.

Having a vested interest control scientific studies is poor regulatory system design.

Re:It’s time all clinical trial results are reported by refurb on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @07:16PM (#5100567)
So who controls the budgets or do you just hand the "independent entity" a pile of cash and let them do what they want?

Also, drug companies often hire physicians and researchers (often the best ones) to help with drug development far before any trial is run. Would you like to exclude those experts from input on the trial design?

From your comment I get the sense you have a limited understanding of what is really involved in drug development.

Re:It’s time all clinical trial results are reported by justsee on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @10:18PM (#5101167)
If we agree that a conflict-of-interest free system is the goal (and non-negotiable) then an independent entity is essential in a properly-functioning regulatory system.

However you appear to have retired undefeated as devil's advocate, as if the questions you put are unanswerable.

I would admit that there are more questions and answers that need to be given before we fully implement my HN comment, but that is hardly a refutation of the core idea: that a system free of conflict-of-interest requires independent entities and umpires that are more empowered than the conflicted interests in that system.

A recent Forbes opinion piece has its own take on inserting independent entities into the system [0]:

What we need is a construct with teeth, an established network of industry-independent researchers (not contractors) equipped to evaluate trial design, statistical power, data analysis, and interpretation, not as regulators but as contributors to final research publications. It would be a sort of Congressional Budget Office for clinical trial results.

Admittedly the position outlined in that article does not go as far as a completely independent entity operating all clinical trials for the purposes of regulatory approval, but it's in the right direction.

[0] http://www.forbes.com/sites/emilywillingham/2012/11/26/how-c...

Re:It’s time all clinical trial results are reported by refurb on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @11:26PM (#5101362)
The issue is not independent entities, it is the unwillingness of the gov't to use the powers it has.

For example, Pfizer was found guilty of promoting Bextra off label, a very serious charge from the viewpoint of the FDA and the Justice Department. Punishment includes banning companies from doing business with CMS (who run Medicare and Medicaid).

Pfizer entered into an agreement with the Justice Department/HHS where a shell company was allowed to plead guilty and be banned from doing business with Medicare. That's right, a shell company that doesn't actually sell any drugs.

http://www.cnn.com/2010/HEALTH/04/02/pfizer.bextra/index.htm...

Re:It’s time all clinical trial results are reported by justsee on Wednesday January 23, 2013 @04:20AM (#5102228)
Who said the issue was independent entities? That's the solution. The issue is conflicted interests having too much influence.

I'd agree the unwillingness of the gov't to use the powers it has is a problem. But that's a separate and equally important issue that others in this thread have flagged, filed under the label 'regulatory capture'.

It's not a situation that requires fire and brimstone and outrage. It should just be approached with dispassionate understanding: we have a defective system that is not designed to withstand attacks by self-interested system 'hackers'.

The solution is to design a system that neutralises short-term, narrow self-interest.

Re:It’s time all clinical trial results are reported by badgar on Wednesday January 23, 2013 @12:00AM (#5101468)
What would the short- to medium-term impact on the poor and elderly be if all Pfizer inventories suddenly weren't available? Are you sure it's worth it?
Re:It’s time all clinical trial results are reported by ekianjo on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @08:01PM (#5100728)
You have no idea how clinical trials work. There's no such simple solution in sight. At best you can ask for more transparency, but "independent" entities will not provide you much of a relief and will cause other issues, too.
Re:It’s time all clinical trial results are reported by christogreeff on Wednesday January 23, 2013 @02:33AM (#5101993)
I do not think you have worked in the clinical trial field, because it seems you have no idea how it actually works.

Publishing every single trial will probably also make more expensive.

Re:It’s time all clinical trial results are reported by kyro on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @06:36PM (#5100368)
You may be right and I may have gotten too zealous there, but more transparency is definitely needed as well as tighter regulations regarding the disclosure and involvement of funding parties.
Re:It’s time all clinical trial results are reported by ianfernz on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @05:11PM (#5099952)
My thoughts exactly. How many lives would this save? I think on the order of several thousand a year, minimum.
Re:It’s time all clinical trial results are reported by ekianjo on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @08:00PM (#5100723)
> It's amazing how we have organizations like Consumer Reports to give us objective reviews of toasters and cars, yet nothing like that exists for medications or medical devices, isn't it?

That's what you get when you end up with an overly-regulated market for drugs. You cannot publish anything about them without governmental authorization.

I agree with the premise of the petition but a petition is a very weak tool to reach that goal. It will get you nowhere.

Re:It’s time all clinical trial results are reported by jgamman on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @08:12PM (#5100761)
i think the root cause has more to do with under-regulation, regulatory capture and proactive efforts to confuse and blur the boundaries. Bad Pharma is a good intro if you care to move past entry level comments.
Re:It’s time all clinical trial results are reported by ekianjo on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @09:28PM (#5101016)
Haha. I have read Bad Pharma and I have been following Goldacre for years and I agree mostly with what he says. Please do not assume my ignorance just because I disagree with your view.

I fail to see where there is "under-regulation" in the pharma industry. Try setting up a Pharma business, you will be surprised how hard it has become.