Do you have a link to the study about mouse vs cell-based key movement?
I have a couple of questions:
- While I fully believe that navigating by mouse is faster, on a desktop the overhead of switching between typing and mousing is quite high. On my laptop I often use the trackpoint over relevant keyboard shortcuts because it's already right under my fingers, but on my desktop I much prefer using the shortcuts due to the overhead of switching.
- For a movement that's three cells or fewer, I find it hard to imagine that mouse would be faster (unless perhaps it's set to follow the cursor?). I assume the study averages over a variety of distances across the entire screen. I hope that most vim users aren't using hjkl for adjustments of more than three or so cells. A combination of {}wb and especially ?/ will handle the bulk of jumps quickly. hjkl are then useful keys for adjusting just a couple of characters to refine your jump -- and now they're already right under your fingers.
There's a slowdown associated with considering too many different options, too, btw. It's just more invisible.