I call this attitude "I'm only single because I'm not picky enough". Kind of how people interviewing for programming jobs are self-selected to have a real problem with FizzBuzz, this seems to be a very common issue with online dating. I haven't seen any sites that try to address it, and don't really have any idea as to how they would.
So do I... in their 30s'. But in my case, that's why they're all still (deservedly) single