News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What we discovered about InstallMonetizer by swampthing on Monday January 21, 2013 @01:59PM (#5093034)
Just because you or I might find something to be a nuisance, doesn't mean most end-users will. Done right, I can easily see unsophisticated end-users being appreciative at being offered useful software that they would otherwise have not known about. I see this crap on my mom's computer all the time - she's bothered by it only if it affects performance or pops up with some message. If it's just sitting there, or if she actually uses it, she couldn't care less how it got there.
Re:What we discovered about InstallMonetizer by watty on Monday January 21, 2013 @03:38PM (#5093622)
Do you really think "most end-users" prefer the stuff that IM installs? Come on.
Re:What we discovered about InstallMonetizer by swampthing on Monday January 21, 2013 @04:06PM (#5093765)
"Prefer" is a higher bar than "don't care" / "not a nuisance".

I don't know what IM installs - but I see Norton on their webpage. I can easily see "most end-users" installing something, seeing the opportunity to install Norton Anti-Virus, and thinking to themselves "oh yea, that sounds like that'd be useful".

Just about everybody on HN is extremely technically savvy - we can't assume that our computing preferences are shared by "most end-users". Note that I am just responding to the assertion that "it['s] hard to believe that [PG] truly think[s] it is anything but a nuisance to end-users".

Re:What we discovered about InstallMonetizer by TeMPOraL on Monday January 21, 2013 @05:00PM (#5093986)
Of what value to users can be a piece of software that they never heard of, don't know what it does and don't feel a need for it? Were they having a problem they wanted solved, they'd intentionally look for the software.

> we can't assume that our computing preferences are shared by "most end-users".

Those are still anecdotes, but I think most of us actually can say this or that about end-users preferences, after countless of hours spent on cleaning their computers. I for one think that calling it "nuisance" is a massive understatement.

Re:What we discovered about InstallMonetizer by chii on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @02:12AM (#5095985)
if you ask these non-technical end users whether they rather have the free software that comes with some crapware, or have to purchase a paid version (of the same software), i think you would find most would choose the free version.

While i dislike the idea of crapware, if it funds useful pieces of software, perhaps its a nuisance that could be tolerated.

Re:What we discovered about InstallMonetizer by SyneRyder on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @04:04AM (#5096251)
Norton is not a current advertiser (neither is Bing or Real), assuming Withinrafael is correct about how the Offer Screens are gathered. See his post about how to download & view the offer screens here:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5086435

Quoting Rafael: "You'll find they only have 42 current advertisers... and not Norton/others listed on the site."