News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How can I send a secure email? by ColinWright on Monday January 21, 2013 @12:56PM (#5092676)
That's "Threat" mode, not "Thread" mode.

Do you want to defend against:

* ... someone in their office reading the email if your accountant's computer is left unattended?

* ... your ISP storing the email and reading it?

* ... their ISP storing the email and reading it?

* ... someone sniffing the packets through a router?

* ... the NSA reading the emails?

If you want your accountant not to have to do anything, then you need something like storing the emails and/or documents on an "https" only server, and then sending them a link. Given your comment about not wanting them to have to do anything, this will be one way only, and they won't be able to reply securely.

Sending them an encrypted email and asking them to read it will, I believe, require them to set something up, and you seem to have ruled that out.

You could use something like a password in a standard document format, and then phone and tell them the password separately. I think you can password lock Microsoft Word files, for example. Not very secure, but secure enough against idle sniffing. Probably not secure against a full on attack by someone seriously capable.

So, again, against what, exactly, are you defending?

Re:Ask HN: How can I send a secure email? by MarkMc on Monday January 21, 2013 @01:26PM (#5092834)
At the risk of being too inexact: I want to defend against all those things, although I don't think it's practical to defend against someone in his office looking over his shoulder or reading his screen when he gets up to make a coffee.

Using a password-protected Microsoft Word file is an option, but it's a little cumbersome because (a) I would also have to password-protect the other attachment files separately; and (b) he would have to reply with a password-protected Microsoft word file and individually password-protect any files he wants to send me.

I like the idea of an https server, but why won't my accountant be able to reply? That is, accountant clicks a link to the https site, puts in password, sees message, clicks the 'reply' button on the webpage, then I get an email saying 'click here to see your accountants reply'.

Re:Ask HN: How can I send a secure email? by ColinWright on Monday January 21, 2013 @01:34PM (#5092885)
With regards defending against the NSA - I believe you have no chance.

With regards the password protected Word files, yes, you would have to protected every attachment, and your accountant would have to password protect every document in the reply. But what else would you expect?

With the https server, will you implement the mail package? In other words, what "Reply" button? Even then, the document will be stored in clear on the server, so whoever owns it will be able to read them. So that had better be you.