News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My experiences with Hacker News. by chris_wot on Monday January 21, 2013 @08:53AM (#5091430)
I have to agree. Flag the article, but don't moan if it gets on the font page. It'll go soon enough.
Re:My experiences with Hacker News. by huhtenberg on Monday January 21, 2013 @08:55AM (#5091437)
They took away my Flag option when Steve Jobs died, after I flagged all but one Jobs-related posts on the front page.

I really don't like navel gazing posts. "How much traffic I got from HN", "What I learned from being on the front page", "How I was brewing my coffee when I hit the front page", etc. This is self-centric bullshit that may with some effort be turned into an interesting discussion, but it is not inherently interesting, leave alone being notable. It's neither N nor is it H.

Re:My experiences with Hacker News. by DanBC on Monday January 21, 2013 @09:38AM (#5091628)
There are some articles which you don't find interesting. One option is to flag those articles. You've lost your ability to flag.

Why do you think that commenting on these articles, especially with strongly negative content free sentences, is the right thing to do?

> I really don't like navel gazing posts. "How much traffic I got from HN", "What I learned from being on the front page", "How I was brewing my coffee when I hit the front page", etc. This is self-centric bullshit that may with some effort be turned into an interesting discussion, but it is not inherently interesting, leave alone being notable. It's neither N nor is it H.

The fact that those posts are so common, and voted up, seem to imply that for many people they are inherently interesting.

But let's assume that you're correct. Your options are to flag, to ignore, to add to the signal, or to add to the noise. You chose to add to the noise! That feels really sub-optimal to me.

Re:My experiences with Hacker News. by huhtenberg on Monday January 21, 2013 @09:46AM (#5091662)
> Why do you think that commenting on these articles, especially with strongly negative content free sentences, is the right thing to do?

I posted what I did to dissuade the OP from submitting similar junk to HN in the future. Flagging and ignoring doesn't have quite the same effect as it aims at the effect, not the cause.

Re:My experiences with Hacker News. by chris_wot on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @02:56AM (#5096084)
Except that at the time, all the articles on HN news about Steve Jobs were intensely interesting to a large number of HN participants. Trying to flag them all was pointless, and as Wikipedia contributors would call it, POINTY (disruptive to try to make a point).

Clearly the moderators frowned on this sort of behaviour, so you lost your ability to flag articles. Like I say, don't do that.

Re:My experiences with Hacker News. by huhtenberg on Wednesday January 23, 2013 @04:31AM (#5102266)
Yes, sir.
Re:My experiences with Hacker News. by chris_wot on Wednesday January 23, 2013 @04:48PM (#5105497)
Correction, not don't do that: you can't do that any more. Is that helpful?
Re:My experiences with Hacker News. by chris_wot on Monday January 21, 2013 @08:59AM (#5091459)
That's really fairly disruptive. Don't do that. I'm not really surprised they did this.
Re:My experiences with Hacker News. by huhtenberg on Monday January 21, 2013 @09:22AM (#5091561)
> Don't do that.

Yes, sir.