News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Edward Tufte’s defense of Aaron Swartz and the “marvelous... by danso on Sunday January 20, 2013 @01:15PM (#5087601)
I think this is a reasonable post and the distinctions are important. However, perhaps Tufte would argue that he (Tufte) knew what he was doing was illegal, especially if done in order to self-profit...and IIRC, other blue-boxers who had some profit-motive were not given such a light treatment when caught.

In contrast, from Aaron's point-of-view, what Aaron was doing was not explicitly illegal. From his admittedly skewed vantage point, he was only freeing what should be public...the FBI stalking of him after the PACER incident likely reaffirmed in his mind that information that is legally available for free will often be blocked by the powers-that-be, just because.

Of course, as we know now, his miscalculation was that JSTOR's archives were not (not all of them, anyway) in the same public status as the PACER documents.

I don't mean to start a new debate over whether Aaron was at fault for not thinking things through more...I'm just pointing out how Tufte could reasonably have empathy for Aaron despite the obvious differences in motive and execution of their schemes.

Re:Edward Tufte’s defense of Aaron Swartz and the “marvelous... by jacquesm on Sunday January 20, 2013 @01:28PM (#5087652)
> Of course, as we know now, his miscalculation was that JSTOR's archives were not (not all of them, anyway) in the same public status as the PACER documents.

Is there any evidence that was a miscalculation?

Re:Edward Tufte’s defense of Aaron Swartz and the “marvelous... by gluejar on Sunday January 20, 2013 @09:47PM (#5089548)
A significant part of the JSTOR corpus is out of copyright. I expect that Aaron meant to do with that subset what he had done with PACER.
Re:Edward Tufte’s defense of Aaron Swartz and the “marvelous... by danso on Sunday January 20, 2013 @01:56PM (#5087729)
To my knowledge, no (if you mean a blog post in which he explicitly states it). I'm just inferring from the disbelief and shock he apparently experienced when prosecutors chose to follow through.

If you mean if there was evidence whether he was wrong about the legality of distributing JSTOR documents...there seems to be some confusion about it, but it doesn't seem that many of Aaron's most legally-mindful defenders have said that freeing JSTOR was just as non-criminal as freeing PACER.

Re:Edward Tufte’s defense of Aaron Swartz and the “marvelous... by ghshephard on Sunday January 20, 2013 @05:23PM (#5088513)
It should be noted, that you can login to JSTOR and read much of the content freely now. Albeit - only three articles at a time in your "bookshelf".

I wouldn't find it at all surprising if the various universities/journals/research bodies figure out how to make this research, much (majority) of which has been paid for by the public, available to the public.

I am one of the most "pro-ip-protection/opposed to copyright infringement" people on HN, and look down on anyone who violates producers/authors rights on commercial content - but I firmly stand with Aaron on the "Make research knowledge free to everyone" side.

Re:Edward Tufte’s defense of Aaron Swartz and the “marvelous... by Anechoic on Sunday January 20, 2013 @01:33PM (#5087666)
I'm just pointing out how Tufte could reasonably have empathy for Aaron [..]

Agreed, I was more responding to jacquesm than to Tufte.