News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Carmen Ortiz Strikes Out by whyenot on Saturday January 19, 2013 @03:38PM (#5084664)
Elsevier et al have done very well selling articles bundled as journal subscriptions. Claiming articles have no commercial value while at the same time railing against publishers is cognitive dissonance at its finest.
Re:Carmen Ortiz Strikes Out by OmarIsmail on Saturday January 19, 2013 @03:45PM (#5084686)
His point is that the scholarly articles (like diamonds) can be easily tracked, and therefore determined if illegally sold or not. Since legitimate buyers - University professors, etc - want to be sure they are on the up and up, the won't purchase illegally obtained goods. Therefore, there would have been no buyers for the articles "stolen".
Re:Carmen Ortiz Strikes Out by Natsu on Saturday January 19, 2013 @03:59PM (#5084721)
Exactly. I can't believe that Aaron would have been able to sell them, even if he had intended to. And I can't seriously believe that he ever intended to, or that the prosecutors could have truly believed that he intended to.

Yes, they are doing that themselves. But hopefully not for much longer if the internet has anything to say about that. I applaud all of the scientists who are working hard to make their research more open.

Re:Carmen Ortiz Strikes Out by MichaelSalib on Saturday January 19, 2013 @04:37PM (#5084862)
That doesn't make sense.

Imagine a world where Swartz managed to destroy JSTOR. A professor asks his grad students to read an article. They can either dig it out of the archival stacks and read it there or wait for interlibrary loan or...use a torrented copy or illegal DVD they bought on the street at their last academic conference. There is no way to track which one they did. No one will ever know. And no one will care: all the prof cares about is whether his students read the damn article; he doesn't care how they got it. He's completely focused on getting his research done, writing grant proposals, etc.

Re:Carmen Ortiz Strikes Out by smsm42 on Saturday January 19, 2013 @05:17PM (#5085007)
Swartz never intended to destroy JSTOR. He wanted to provide access to the articles (many of them, I'm sure, public financed and should be publicly accessible anyway) to people that do not have 50K/year to pay to JSTOR. That would by no way destroy JSTOR, but if the access to the storage could be provided much cheaper - in theory, if it would be possible to do all the functions of JSTOR without JSTOR - I see no reason why JSTOR should be sacred.
Re:Carmen Ortiz Strikes Out by MichaelSalib on Saturday January 19, 2013 @05:27PM (#5085037)
With respect, the fact that he wrote the Guerilla Open Access Manifesto suggests that he did want to destroy JSTOR as a going concern. Now, maybe he didn't think releasing their archive would be enough, but he was clearly gunning for them.

He wanted to provide access to the articles to people that do not have 50K/year to pay to JSTOR. That would by no way destroy JSTOR

JSTOR prorates its fees so that poor institutions pay much less than rich institutions. And all of Africa gets JSTOR for free. Now, even individuals can get capped free articles from JSTOR.

If the JSTOR archive was released to the world, why would journal owners continue licensing their content to JSTOR?

Finally, do you understand that most of what JSTOR charges pays for either licensing the journal content (JSTOR doesn't own copyright for the journals it includes) or for scanning/digitizing new content? The costs that JSTOR charges pay for a hell of a lot more than a few web sites pushing PDFs to clients.

Re:Carmen Ortiz Strikes Out by smsm42 on Monday January 21, 2013 @03:48AM (#5090593)
>>>> If the JSTOR archive was released to the world, why would journal owners continue licensing their content to JSTOR?

I'm not sure how this question makes sense. If the content that is accessible via JSTOR would be also accessible otherwise, which journal owners would withhold permission from JSTOR to publish their content? That's like saying if the book is available in the library, nobody would ever buy it. Obviously, it is not so.

Also, surprisingly, in September 2011 JSTOR made public domain content available to everybody and shortly after that instituted free individual access programs - which they didn't do before, and which by your words should be impossible due to high costs that can not be supported in any other way but by charging for any access. Somehow it turned out to be possible still, and JSTOR did not collapse.

Re:Carmen Ortiz Strikes Out by MichaelSalib on Saturday January 19, 2013 @07:46PM (#5085477)
Wow, downvoters really don't want anyone to know about how JSTOR is free for institutions in Africa or prorates its costs for poorer institutions the world over!

I wonder if Swartz, who was very concerned about information access in the global south (according to his manifesto), knew about that.

Re:Carmen Ortiz Strikes Out by jlgreco on Saturday January 19, 2013 @05:22PM (#5085025)
> if it would be possible to do all the functions of JSTOR without JSTOR

And spoilers: it's not. In order to make it would you would have to recreate everything JSTOR currently does, which would result in a JSTOR not called JSTOR. One with legal liability at that.

Re:Carmen Ortiz Strikes Out by smsm42 on Monday January 21, 2013 @02:38PM (#5093261)
It may very well be so, then the project of copying JSTOR would be marginal and would descend into oblivion without any external intervention.