Re:The Value of Downvoting, or, How Hacker News Gets It Wrong
by codinghorror on Monday March 09, 2009 @08:20PM
(#509308)
> This is a simpler approach
Having a secret cabal of editors, whose behavior and rules are not documented, is simpler than spending karma to vote against things? Really?
Re:The Value of Downvoting, or, How Hacker News Gets It Wrong
by tptacek on Monday March 09, 2009 @09:43PM
(#509384)
Yes. A lot.
Re:The Value of Downvoting, or, How Hacker News Gets It Wrong
by codinghorror on Monday March 09, 2009 @11:10PM
(#509447)
can you elaborate?
Re:The Value of Downvoting, or, How Hacker News Gets It Wrong
by tptacek on Monday March 09, 2009 @11:46PM
(#509483)
What's there to say? Submitters veer off topic. You hit the "flag" button. The story gets marked "dead". How is my life improved by the prospect of having more work to do to groom the site?
It's like people used to say about micropayments; all these little knobs exact a mental cost; I have to spend 5 cycles deciding what to do --- mod up? mod down? what are other people doing? do I need to care?
Seems to me like Hacker News is doing the Simplest Thing That Could Possibly work. A good thing.
Re:The Value of Downvoting, or, How Hacker News Gets It Wrong
by codinghorror on Tuesday March 10, 2009 @03:28AM
(#509659)
The simplest thing is finding and blessing 30 people with the right to kill flagged entries? And trusting those 30 people to do the right thing?
Wouldn't it be simpler to automate the whole thing, and let the algorithm do the work?
Having said that, the 2-1 downvote scheme you proposed does put some of us within spitting distance of taking nickb down to zero, so I support it wholeheartedly.