Basically, it's a zero sum game. So if everybody paid for the reviews they did and then got paid for doing reviews, a lot of money would change hands and everybody would end up with the same amount of money they had to start with.
Of course, the companies that _publish_ the journals take a cut. But that's what it is, a cut. There are really communities of professors participating in a zero sum game.
The companies that publish the journals don't take a cut, they take the lion's share basically, paying a professor to review would work better in having them take a share of the pie.
In the former case, you are incentivizing people to do reviews who are not actually qualified to do them. Or, incentivizing people to do more reviews than they have time to do a good job on.
In the latter case, there's not really any point.
If you think your reviews are valuable, charge accordingly. You provide value to the publishing process and should capture that value. You are providing the service of "expertise". If you provided that service to a lawyer, you would earn several hundred dollars an hour.
There's probably a business opportunity in creating a clearinghouse for reviewers, editors, etc. and managing the accounting.
Edit: Grammaring more goodly