Re:Genetic evidence suggests that, four millennia ago, India...
by jacquesm on Friday January 18, 2013 @07:54AM
(#5078385)
Max Planck Gesellschaft publication on this:
http://www.mpg.de/6818105/Holocene-gene-flow_India-Australia
> There are more than a dozen mistakes in it.
Could you please point those out?
Re:Genetic evidence suggests that, four millennia ago, India...
by arethuza on Friday January 18, 2013 @08:27AM
(#5078492)
'imaginary dating of the "Indian civilization"'
The 23rd centry BC seems to be right in the middle of the peak of the Indus Valley Civilisation:
Re:Genetic evidence suggests that, four millennia ago, India...
by Jamiecon on Friday January 18, 2013 @07:53AM
(#5078380)
Economist articles have no byline as editorial policy.
Can't comment on the rest of your points.
Re:Genetic evidence suggests that, four millennia ago, India...
by cschmidt on Friday January 18, 2013 @10:04AM
(#5078936)
That's an interestingly emotional, defensive response. Most HN readers would simply have found it an cool scientific article. I don't think the Economist science section really has a "propaganda" axe to grind. (And as others have said, they never sign articles.) What's the source of your reaction?
Re:Genetic evidence suggests that, four millennia ago, India...
by pyre on Friday January 18, 2013 @11:51AM
(#5079576)
It could just hit close to home. These anthropological 'origin stories' sometimes contradict racial identity. For example, if you were to suggest that the Japanese were descended from Korean farmers that emigrated from mainland Korean, many Japanese would find that offensive because there is deep racial hatred of Korea (though maybe only truly present in the older generations) and a racial identity of being natives to Japan.
Re:Genetic evidence suggests that, four millennia ago, India...
by jlgreco on Friday January 18, 2013 @12:40PM
(#5079858)
I wonder if English have ever felt similar offense when people point out the role of France and the french language in their country's and language's development.
Re:Genetic evidence suggests that, four millennia ago, India...
by willyt on Friday January 18, 2013 @02:55PM
(#5080604)
Nope. When I realised, I thought holy shit, I pretty much speak French already. Learn some glue words then any word ending in 'able' or 'cial' (and a few others i forget) pronounced in a 'Allo 'Allo [0] accent and you are pretty likely to be talking French. :-)
[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allo_Allo!
Re:Genetic evidence suggests that, four millennia ago, India...
by chc on Friday January 18, 2013 @06:48PM
(#5081836)
I think for the most part they're pretty well aware of the Latin influence on their language. But you might be interested in Googling "Anglish" for the (rather fringe) pushback against the ancient foreign incursion.
Re:Genetic evidence suggests that, four millennia ago, India...
by lrhot9 on Friday January 18, 2013 @08:10AM
(#5078432)
Is this a trailer for a highbrow dismissal?
Re:Genetic evidence suggests that, four millennia ago, India...
by carbocation on Friday January 18, 2013 @08:31AM
(#5078502)
You allude to many things but don't state counterpoints. Would you please elaborate?
There is no name of the author on the article either. I wonder if this is propaganda, pure carelessness or something else. Did the Zurich guys even approve publishing such non-sense?