News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by rdl on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:01PM (#5069933)
I think it's natural to say "oh, big high profile event involved people getting shot with a scary looking gun, so let's solve the problem by banning those scary-looking guns". Add to that that almost none of the legislators or members of their staff have any actual experience with or knowledge of weapons, and it becomes easy to push bad policy.

I actually think this is a brilliant plan by President Obama. Push a bunch of things (some of which no reasonable person could oppose, like the efficiency improvements in the EOs), and some things which the Republicans in the House will probably not let get out of committee or to a vote on the floor (AWB and magazine capacity limits).

That way, the President gets to accomplish some things (and some of those things which have costs are things a lot of gun owners, myself included, support -- 100% NCIC checks on all transfers). The Republicans who block AWB get painted as obstructionists for blocking part of that, which hurts them from the center/left. Some Tea Party/etc. people push even wackier candidates in 2014 if the Republicans compromise on any issues at all, thus helping the Democrats in 2014, too.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by anigbrowl on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:11PM (#5069976)
An astute analysis - I disaagree only insofar as I think the magazine limits will prevail in some form. The AWB rpobably won't and is a political sacrifice as you say, but I think the manufacturers o such weapons are on the cusp of a long-term decline - this ad by Bushmaster [1] exemplifies what many people find repellent about gun culture/ Although gun sales are high right now and will surely rocket higher in the short term in response to these proposals, I think opposition to more regulation will decline over the longer term in the same way as opposition to gay marriage - because the sky never does get around to falling, and people get used to the idea and accept it.

Incidentally, I was surprised to be reminded by the President's speech that the BATF hasn't had a full-time director the last 6 years.

1. http://cdn03.cdnwp.thefrisky.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/...

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by Cushman on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:24PM (#5070058)
> 1. http://cdn03.cdnwp.thefrisky.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/...

Sexism aside (since it's hardly specific to gun culture), that actually seems like pretty sincere marketing for something whose main real selling point is that it makes a very loud noise.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by rdl on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:22PM (#5070039)
AP ammo possession is the most likely to pass; no one really cares about that.

Mag limits are less likely than AP ammo. I honestly have no idea how likely or not they are to pass. I'm pretty well hedged :)

AWB seems hopeless, both because it's clearly cosmetic and ineffectual and because it would have a higher cost to implement.

Also, I agree the long-term trend is anti-firearms, mainly due to immigration and urbanization. However, the trend within firearms is from shotgun/lever/revolver toward "America's Rifle" (AR-15), military style accessories, tactical training, etc.

I also think if you took a direct 100% popular vote right now (or especially the day after Sandy Hook), 50+% of people would vote for banning all guns. A majority of people would also support confiscating the assets of the richest 1%, etc., though.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by hga on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:43PM (#5070151)
Mag limits would also have a terrific political cost.

Not noticed by many outside the community is that most handguns for self-defense, and many if not most that are used for concealed carry, have standard magazine capacities of > 10 rounds (and almost all > 7 rounds).

De jure or de facto shall issue concealed carry regimes are now in place in 42 states, and scholar Clayton Cramer and the Government Accountability Office (GAO) independently estimated this summer that there are between 7.5 and 8 million licenses outstanding (and more every day, especially as the US population ages). Screwing with these people, who tend to vote (older demographic, after all) ... is not wise. Just threatening them, as is being done now, will have costs in the coming elections.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by rdl on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @08:10PM (#5070248)
A 10rd magazine limit basically becomes the "1911 as national handgun act of 2013". It might finally push Glock into making single-stack 9mm, .40s&w, and larger-than-36 .45acp weapons, though.
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by hga on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @08:26PM (#5070326)
The M1911 has fit my hand perfectly since I was a teen and I can shoot them really well, so I'm a member of the church of John Moses Browning (PBUH).

And that's exactly what happened in the 1994-2004 period; there were plenty of standard capacity magazines for existing designs, but they got a lot more expensive and there was always the concern you might eventually use up all the ones you could procure. And for new designs....

Well, .45 ACP indeed became a lot more popular; if you're limited to 10+1 rounds or less you'd better make every one count. And M1911s ... well, everyone makes them nowadays. Even Remington returned to the handgun market with one. Despite thinking it's the best design---and certainly they don't fit everyone's hands, like the Glock doesn't for me---I'm just amazed. Of course, the design is long past patent protection, I'm sure someone has a affordable CNC package for them, and then it's just normal fitting. But, still.

And it's a century year old design!

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by strlen on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @08:38PM (#5070379)
I really like my 1911 (Kimber Target II, so ready for arguments about metal injection molding...), but it's really an enthusiast's gun at this point. I would not recommend it to a non-expert looking to use it for actual protection. I usually suggest moving, a dog, a shotgun, and CZ 75-B or Glock 17/19 (in that order).

An early-to-mid-20th century American soldier (US has always emphasized pistols as actual combat weapons more than other countries[1]) or a modern shooting sports enthusiast has the time and skill to clean one periodically (as to keep it in working state) and perform adjustments to prevent jams.

It's not reasonable to expect this of someone with no previous experience of firearms, but looking to protect themselves after receiving a death threat or seeing too many home invasions in their neighborhood. Doubly so if it's a Kimber or other model made to far tighter tolerance than was possible or intended in 1911.

These laws tend to benefit hunters, hobbyists, and target shooters like myself (who prefer muzzle brakes to flash hiders, match-grade full-length barrels to tactical coolness, etc...), but hurt people who want to use these weapons for self-defense.

[1] First trophy my grandfather (artillery captain in Soviet military) took during World War II was a Walther PPK in .32 ACP. Not ideal for defense, but far cry from a Nagant or a Tokarev TT (based on the 1911, but unsafe for carrying with the hammer cocked). Never heard of an American officer trading his 1911 for a Walther/Nambu/Luger/etc...

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by hga on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @08:59PM (#5070475)
Well, some of the answers to your points are:

Don't buy a target gun, buy one specifically made to looser tolerances for self-defense. The design is very forgiving after all, it was for the field and back in a period when ammo was often marginal (hence its grossly overpowered mainspring, Mauser style positive feed and claw extractor, etc.).

I've never had to adjust any of mine to prevent jams or other problems once I got past one obnoxious one of my Kimber Pro-Carry flinging its brass into my face (slow and careful filing of the ejector fixed that). They can also get pretty dirty without needing cleaning. But, they are self-defense models, not target ones, they aren't super tight, although they're more accurate than I am with a handgun.

As for your other suggestions: moving can be a good idea but you might stil be tracked down, a dog can be killed (it was recently joked that the police could solve their ammo shortages if they just stopped shooting dogs), a shotgun is a really, really bad idea for weapons retention. Someone can grab it outside of your grip and rip it out of your hands, as I demonstrated to a nephew who's bigger and fitter than me. If a M1911 is too advanced for someone to learn I do recommend an external hammer DAO design (since carrying is a consideration striker fired guns are right out due to the holstering accidental discharge problem (not being able to detect that until it fires)).

And following the church of Martin Fackler, I recommend going for the biggest diameter that works for the person, i.e. .45 ACP > .40 S&W > 9 mm.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by strlen on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @11:02PM (#5070869)
I'll defer the self-defense suggestions to you: I live in a "carry is strictly a political favour" county, so I haven't looked at cary molds of 1911s... I think you're probably far more familiar with this than I am.

I don't, however, think that a normal Stainless Kimber is better (tolerance-wise) than the Target model. The only distinction (afaik) are the adjustable sights (which are actually amazingly sturdy for adjustable sights, to my surprised). You clear know more self-defense than I do -- so I'll defer to you (especially re: shotguns, etc...)

Re: other suggestions--

I was not covering the "I have a determined nutcase after me" scenario, I was covering the "increase in violent crime" (armed robbery, home invasions, etc...) scenario. I've had these questions recently because (for many reasons) San Jose has had a drastic increase in crime: moving to Saratoga/Cupertino/good part of Sunnyvale or to Fremont seems like a good long term strategy anyway.

To clarify re: dog, I wasn't suggesting having the dog attack the assailant, but more in the sense of having a dog wake me (and the immediate neighbors) up if a stranger is around at night.

Of course this is not a very reliable strategy, being in a safe neighborhood (with trustworthy neighbors), and having a firearm are far more important. However, it's useful: an alarm system only works if it's tripped, but a dog can smell from a distance. So far, the only times my dog has waken me up at night, was literally when there was a stranger directly in front of the downstairs living room windows.

Not in any way perfect, but sufficient to alert the neighbors, scare away a robber that has purely financial motivation, let me call the police, etc... before they attempt to break in (best confrontation is one that never has to happen).

I agree that the trend of police shooting family dogs is absolutely disgusting, but so is the trend of paramilitary police raiding family homes on shoddy evidence.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by rdl on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:06PM (#5070499)
I'm a bit torn. Absent mag capacity, I'm a firm believer in 9mm -- 124gr Speer Gold Dot Hollow Point (+P sometimes). If I'm stuck with FMJ, .45acp obviously.

My favorite guns are Sig SAOs -- I've got a few X-Fives, and P220 SAOs, and a fair number of DA/SA and a couple DAK too. Really tempted by the new P226 SAO which came out yesterday -- I'd love a P229 SAO though, or an "X-Three" or something. Also really like CZ -- I started out carrying a Browning Hi-Power in Iraq (along with an AK), and then moved my way up to a CZ-97b once I had a reliable source of .45acp FMJ ammo. The only 1911s I have are Dan Wesson (awesome) and Taurus (no idea why I bought them except that they were $399 and I was stupid). I'd like to get a Wilson or Les Baer and some of the new Sig, Ruger, and S&W 1911s.

For a competition, I'd take tested/tuned P220 SAO or X-Five, but if I had to grab something out of the factory box and rely on it for 6 months with no prior testing, it would be a Glock 19 (or maybe a Glock 21 if FMJ-only, but I really prefer the 19). Similarly, if I had to hand a handgun to someone with minimal training, it would be a Glock (or a revolver -- love the 627 PC "8 times")

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by hga on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:30PM (#5070583)
Why are you such a believer in 9 mm? If that hollow point doesn't expand....

The nice thing about .45 ACP is that you aren't betting much on it expanding, and if it does, all things equal, if you follow Fackler, it'll be better than a similarly expanding 9 mm.

No argument with Gold Dot, that's what I use in .45 ACP. For me the question of "which gun" was settled by the ergonomics of the M1911 in my hand, obviously YMMV.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by strlen on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @08:30PM (#5070343)
> It might finally push Glock into making single-stack 9mm

As a dude with small hands, I will write a personal letter of thanks to Andrew Cuomo if this happens: a modern polymer single-stack 9mm from a reputable manufacturer is long overdue.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by hga on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @08:36PM (#5070374)
You don't like Kahr's offering?

I get the impression they're good, but I myself can't get past the "no external hammer" for preventing accidental discharges when holstering.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by rdl on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:31PM (#5070588)
Somehow I suspect you also dislike the SERPA style holsters.
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by hga on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @10:27PM (#5070771)
Somehow you've read my mind.
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by rdl on Thursday January 17, 2013 @02:34AM (#5071525)
I'm torn because they do help with weapon retention when holstered (which is generally why I hate open carry), but they do seem to lead to ND into the thigh.
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by hga on Thursday January 17, 2013 @09:42AM (#5072847)
I gather there are many other designs with "proprietary" to the user weapons retention features without that trigger finger moving inwards motion, so you're not limited to the SERPA. In fact I'd argue that all the ones I've heard something about are better because they don't have that big, obvious button on the outside.
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by MartinCron on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:28PM (#5070077)
I also think if you took a direct 100% popular vote right now (or especially the day after Sandy Hook), 50+% of people would vote for banning all guns. A majority of people would also support confiscating the assets of the richest 1%, etc., though.

What a relief that nobody is talking about either banning all guns or confiscating assets.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by andrewflnr on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:24PM (#5070049)
I find the magazine thing kind of funny. Even if we can't quite print guns yet, a magazine of any reasonable capacity ought not to be too hard. I'd be a little surprised if it hasn't been done already.
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by rdl on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:41PM (#5070138)
It's easier to manufacture magazines using regular metalworking process, though. I'd possibly 3d print the follower, but buy great CS springs (potentially scavenge them from 10rd magazines, potentially also with the followers), and then either fix 10rd magazine bodies or just bend some sheet aluminum into the right shape.

The big problem for common weapons like the AR-15 using STANAG 20/30rd magazines is "real" USGI aluminum magazines are still widely available, and cost about $8/ea usually (they just spiked, but a lot of people have tens or hundreds already). The best magazines, Magpul's PMags, are $125 for $10. By the time you 3d print, add springs, etc., it's not worth it.

There's not a whole lot of stress on a magazine (certainly compared to a barrel), but they are subjected to wear, and need to smoothly insert. There are some highly dimensionally sensitive areas as well as flexibility sensitive parts (feed lips) which also change with time. Even the stainless steel magazines basically suck by comparison to Magpul or USGI aluminum, and the Thermold plastic magazines are also lame. The only polymer mags other than pmags that I don't hate are the Lancers.

There probably would be a market in custom or semi-custom manufacture of magazines for more obscure guns, though. Or, if 10rd magazines were completely banned too, and somehow the huge supply of 10-30rd magazines were confiscated.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by anigbrowl on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @10:51PM (#5070832)
I would be unwilling to rely on one that hadn't been machined, assuming it would jam or so. I don't think the idea of a ban is so much about making them impossible to get as making them hard to get casually. As far as I can see the big prize for the administration would be closing the gun show loophole and dealing with the straw purchaser problem (both of which seem like reasonable things to me).
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by gyardley on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:32PM (#5070099)
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by Cushman on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:21PM (#5070034)
I suppose it makes sense as a bargaining chip which will be left on the table, but there's a risk it will actually pass, right? My impression has been that the 1994 AWB did real harm to the image of gun control. If I'm a Republican legislator, can't I actually threaten to vote for it?