News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why You Should Join Diaspora Now, Like Your Freedom Depen... by tanaqot on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @05:37PM (#5069507)
>my mom isn't there, she's on facebook

the problem is that facebook does not allow to friend your mom from other social networks - Diaspora, Friendica, Google Plus, etc.

If it were, you would have your info let's say on your own Diaspora node, and your mom wouldn't have to register in Diaspora network in order to see them. She only would have to friend you from her existing facebook account.

Why it is not possible now? Why we assume this is normal?

The problem is that we don't have good enough anti monopolistic laws that would prohibit facebook to not allow to friend fb users from other networks like Diaspora.

So we could choose service provider, or set up our own, like we can do in case of email servers.

Oh, I forgot - email was designed by scientists, not capitalists. If it were designed by capitalists, it would not allow you to send pics from yahoo to google. Or, big corporations would make agreemensts, like they fight with patents now, but small entrepreneurs wouldn't have the possibility to provide a service, or at list I wouldn't have my own email server. However, now I run my own Diaspora node.

Re:Why You Should Join Diaspora Now, Like Your Freedom Depen... by shmerl on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @05:45PM (#5069549)
E-mail in the early days also prevented users from communicating with users of other servers (most notorious examples were AOL and Compuserve). Eventually under pressure that wall was broken. You can compare it to IM services which use XMPP but don't allow federation, which is one of the main points of XMPP. And Facebook does exactly that with their IM service - they use XMPP but don't federate, thus not allowing their users to communicate with other XMPP networks. Kind of expectable from Facebook ;)
Re:Why You Should Join Diaspora Now, Like Your Freedom Depen... by tanaqot on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @06:10PM (#5069679)
amazing. When I was writing "e-mail" I meant SMTP based post. AOL used SMTP, which is Internet standard and defined by RFC and yet prohibited from communicating with other servers? wow. are you sure? I am in denial. (:
Re:Why You Should Join Diaspora Now, Like Your Freedom Depen... by shmerl on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:33PM (#5070104)
This probably predates SMTP, but I can't find a solid review of this historic issue. I'll look around.

UPDATE: It's mentioned here for example: http://www.michaelrobertson.com/archive.php?minute_id=192