News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by anonymouz on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @08:41AM (#5066711)
Why not ask for an investigation into her behaviour and its connection to the suicide instead?

I have little sympathy for prosecutorial overreach , but it seems somewhat ironic and counterproductive that she should face such harsh consequences without there being at least an attempt to establish the facts of the matter independent of the lynch mob that is now on her heels.

If we allege that she used her position to bully someone, we should at least not fall into the same trap ourselves.

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by joelthelion on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @08:51AM (#5066735)
I think everyone who signs the petition knows that the Obama administration won't fire her like this.

This is mostly to send a message to her and other prosecutors, and to get the Obama administration to examine the problem and give a response.

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by andrewvc on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @04:05PM (#5069028)
That's why I signed as well. The point is that firing should be on the table as the first option. The public needs a DAMN good reason not to fire this prosecutor.

I think we're all well aware that she's probably not the worst prosecutor in the govt. I'm sure others have caused as much harm to those without the fame and network Aaron had. However, these are the people we entrust to uphold our laws, and we need to hold them accountable to justice, not their careers.

Hopefully this is just the start.

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by brudgers on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:41AM (#5066971)
"Why not ask for an investigation"

Lynch mobs have already done all the investigating that needs investigating.

Those grieving Swartz's death have my sympathy. Those fanning their natural anger to vengeance do not.

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by jordanb on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @03:22PM (#5068833)
Cut out the hysterics. She's a political appointee. She serves at the pleasure of the president. And the public is asking for her removal.

Remember when Bush sacked a bunch of US Attorneys for insufficient ideological purity? If not, this might joggle your memory:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dismissal_of_U.S._attorneys_con...

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by brudgers on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @04:14PM (#5069066)
My spouse has spent most of the past twenty years as a clinical social worker at hospice agencies. Stints in between include geriatrics, oncology, and Alzheimer's patients. I've spent some time talking about people's reactions to death and disease. It's not the sort of stuff one leaves at the office. That office includes phone calls at 3am on a Thursday to attend a death.

Getting someone fired won't honor Swartz - at least that's my opinion. It won't change the law - and that's a fact.

I remember the Bush era firings. I didn't think they made a positive change in America. I don't think firing Swartz's prosecutor will either. I think we are better served by people who learn from their mistakes.

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by pstuart on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @04:28PM (#5069147)
Other than protest, what might get the attention of the powers that be that such prosecutorial overreaching is unacceptable?

They have no impetus to change until there's enough anger to make them afraid.

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by brudgers on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @04:43PM (#5069223)
Prosecutorial over-reach is a byproduct of the particular structure of our adversarial system and current views on the role of our legal system. This was not one rogue individual, it was the execution of an institutional mindset that has given us the highest incarceration rate in the world.

Pinning all that on one person allows something to be done without causing change.

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by adventured on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @04:52PM (#5069265)
Getting the appropriate person or people fired in this case is clearly about accountability, not spite / vindictiveness. These people have a lot of power, and that power was abused.

There's nothing that guarantees any of the people involved will learn from their mistakes, but what we do know is that their actions were a terrible injustice. America isn't going to magically become a better place because one person gets fired, but I don't see anybody arguing otherwise. I see people arguing that such a dramatic abuse of power should have consequences, and that is the point.

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by brudgers on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @05:23PM (#5069420)
Reasonable and thoughtful people can disagree about what constitutes abuse. My opinion, though certainly not expert, is that there is nothing unusual about the tactics used in Shwartz's case - they are typical for the agency and prosecutors in general.

This didn't come about overnight. The Feds were sending people to jail for conspiracy to distribute crack cocaine based on the argument that two lovers must have shared it with each other twenty years ago - and those people are only out of prison if they're dead.

It's not dramatic. It's ordinary. Prosecutors treat the courtroom the same way some people treat the golf course - as a place to demonstrate their skill.

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by harryf on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @11:34AM (#5067521)
Looking at Carmen Ortiz's [track record](http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carmen_Ortiz) of cases prosecuting involving corruption and organized crime, seems like this would be hurting one of the "good guys". No doubt she has enemies that must be gloating about the petition
Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by toyg on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @12:06PM (#5067702)
Yeah, because the world is like a Batman comic, right?

When "good guys" screw up, they must take the same responsibility they ask of "bad guys". When "good guys" resort to bully or torture weaker opponents, they are as bad as anyone.

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by harryf on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @01:16PM (#5068170)
Well my point was simply here is someone with a good reputation. Perhaps it's worth understanding exactly what took place crying for revenge.
Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by mstefanko on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @01:36PM (#5068275)
I definitely agree with that notion. I think the problem we're facing is that the general public at this time knows most of what was going on. She's had a good reputation to this point. But she finally picked the wrong person to make an example of. Prosecutorial overreach is a funny thing. In that, her career may have been built on it. If the number of previous people we're actually bad people, the same tactics would of been far more accepted. Since this was a clear abuse of her power, even if it's something prosecutors generally get away with. The idea of making an example out of her seems vengeful and almost hypocritical. But it's not without its grounds.
Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by guiambros on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @06:43PM (#5069837)
Here's a good article on HuffPo, exactly about the ongoing practice - and its incentives - of prosecutorial overreach:

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/16/the-power-of-the-pr...

The whole system is flawed; it rewards high-profile convictions, instead of justice. Wrong success metrics -> wrong job description -> wrong outcome.

So, I have a lot of sympathy for those grieving Swartz's death AND fanning their natural anger to vengeance. They are not at odds. That's why I signed both petitions, and really hoping to see them coming through.

Of course none of this will get her (nor Steve "Is he suicidal? Let's lock him down; the jail is safe" Heymann) fired, but hopefully it'll spark the debate within Obama's administration about the (appropriate) role of prosecutors in this country.

Yeah, call me optimistic.

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by rst on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @04:17PM (#5069090)
As the page notes, some of those cases are also very controversial. Particularly the case of Tarek Mehanna, who was convicted of aiding a terrorist organization for translating some of their documents into English. No evidence was offered that he had assisted with their operations; the criminal offense was letting the rest of us know what they are thinking. (Do you feel safer not knowing? I don't.)

Here's the ACLU page on the Mehanna case:

http://aclum.org/usa_v_mehanna

This case did not result in a suicide; it did, however, feature a sentence of over 17 years.

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by darkarmani on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:39AM (#5066962)
> it seems somewhat ironic and counterproductive that she should face such harsh consequences

Losing her job is a harsh consequence??

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by tych0 on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:43AM (#5066981)
When you're a US attorney, yes. It's not like there's some other federal government you can go work for. Her job market is not as liquid as ours.
Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by mstefanko on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @02:26PM (#5068520)
I don't think it works that way, honestly. The majority of people at that level are so well off that they don't get hit that hard. They don't really get hit at all. They have a million opportunities after being let go. Even looking into someone like Nixon, where do you go from there. He received 2 millions to write his memoirs, was paid millions for interviews etc. I don't doubt it would drastically alter her career, at least from the path she was on. But she has a certain right to uphold a set of ethics, when prosecutors overstep their power, they are no more infallible than you or I. In that role, it's always on the table as a consequence. People keep referencing how she's one of the "good guys" without any real knowledge of her previous work. Her entire career may of been built on top of prosecutorial overreach. When you put away bad people, people don't care how you do it. She finally picked the wrong person to make an example of. But even if she's let go, believe me, she'll do just fine.
Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by darkarmani on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @01:01PM (#5068087)
Seriously, you are equating job loss as a harsh consequence when she threatens 35 years of jail time to people?
Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by Retric on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @10:36AM (#5067216)
Not so much, chances are she is taking a pay cut by working for the federal government.
Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by tych0 on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @10:45AM (#5067251)
Of course, but there are other reasons people work where they do besides money!
Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by anonymouz on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @02:39PM (#5068587)
It's not simply losing a job. It's being targeted by the hateful vengeance of an Internet crowd that is so convinced of the truth of its accusations and that it knows all the relevant facts, that it doesn't even give her a chance to defend herself before casting the judgement over here.

I can only imagine that being in such a position causes a huge amount of stress. It seems very hypocritical to me to one the one hand blame her for driving Aaron Swartz into suicide, and then putting her under similar pressure based on possibly premature conclusions.

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by darkarmani on Thursday January 17, 2013 @01:17AM (#5071330)
> It's being targeted by the hateful vengeance of an Internet crowd that is so convinced of the truth of its accusations and that it knows all the relevant facts, that it doesn't even give her a chance to defend herself before casting the judgement over here.

Versus being targeted by the full weight of the US attorney's office that is so convinced of the truth of its accusations and that it knows all the relevant facts that it piles on trumped up charges to force someone to not defend himself in court?

When the internet crowd has the ability to have her imprisoned against her will, you can compare the situations.

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by jlgreco on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @03:31PM (#5068879)
Similar pressure? In what world are they even comparable?

We are talking about firing someone, not even a weekend in prison. Give me a break.

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by anonymouz on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @04:00PM (#5068999)
We are talking about tens of thousands of people blaming her to be a major factor in someone's death, and wishing to force consequences on her without there being an opportunity for her to make her case.

I have never met either Aaron Swartz or her, but I do know that both, the prospect of a ruinous trial as well as the prospect of being blamed for someones death and being publically shamed out of my position by an angry mob would put me under a huge amount of psychological pressure.

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by rst on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @04:19PM (#5069102)
And the worst possible "consequence" is that she has to find another job. Again, no comparison to what she was putting Swartz through.
Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by sp4rki on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @04:29PM (#5069152)
Being forcibly removed (as in not asked to resign as is usual in the government "circles") would probably have a disastrous effect on the rest of her career, or lack thereof.
Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by jlgreco on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @05:20PM (#5069407)
Yeah, again, no comparison.
Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by anonymouz on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @05:57PM (#5069621)
It seems there is no point in arguing, since it gets continually ignored but once more: Being made responsible for the death of a person is a bit harsher than "getting fired".
Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by darkchasma on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:13AM (#5066817)
I think the point is to demand an internal investigation, and to ensure that destroying peoples lives in order to gain a metric for advancement will not be tolerated.
Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by technoslut on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @11:53AM (#5067617)
I don't believe it was the intent of the petition but it may be the end result.

I saw a story on Techmeme yesterday where the husband of the attorney supposedly said a plea was offered of six months. I'm not sure if the story was true but, if it was, it would put the story in a different light.

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by olefoo on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @02:32PM (#5068548)
The intent of the petition was to put the idea that her behavior was questionable into the Presidents head.

Most likely she's working with her crisis PR team to figure out how to get in front of the issue. Which would involve a complete housecleaning of the office in MA.

See http://bluemassgroup.com/2013/01/its-bigger-than-carmen-orti...

As that article points out she is a political appointee and as such, is a legitimate focus for political outrage.

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by technoslut on Saturday January 19, 2013 @11:07AM (#5083728)
You could be right. I don't know which was my point. There are many who want turn turn Aaron's death into a movement.

I just want to get the story straight to know where I stand.

Re:25,000 People Sign Petition to Remove Aaron Swartz's Pros... by catshirt on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @10:59AM (#5067345)
i see the irony, but couldn't you argue that it is a fair lesson in proportionality?