News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lawmakers slam DOJ prosecution of Swartz as 'ridiculous, ... by wilfra on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @08:29PM (#5064513)
You don't think Congress agreeing with us on this can have any practical effect? You realize they are the ones who make the laws and confirm judicial appointments, right?

I know it's cool to hate on the government and criticize everything they ever do and assume they are all idiots - and most of the time they deserve it - but if they are on our side on this that should be welcomed and they should be given credit for it.

Re:Lawmakers slam DOJ prosecution of Swartz as 'ridiculous, ... by beatpanda on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @08:33PM (#5064539)
My point is that I don't think Congress actually agrees on this. Zoe Lofgren represents Silicon Valley. Making statements like this could just as easily be trawling for votes as it could be genuine outrage over the issue.

No Congressperson ever said these things while Swartz was still alive, and his prosecution was just as ridiculous then, but saying so wouldn't have netted you nearly the positive media coverage in the tech press that it will now.

Re:Lawmakers slam DOJ prosecution of Swartz as 'ridiculous, ... by intenex on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @09:18PM (#5064745)
Um. We didn't do anything much either before he killed himself. I think it's fantastic that they're on Aaron's side here - yes, it's unfortunate that it took his death to make them on his side, but that blame lies with all of us, not the lawmakers.

We made this a big deal after his death, consequently leading to the politicians making their claims now. Had we made a big deal before he died, perhaps the lawmakers would have done the same.

Our fault, not theirs. They really are representing us here.

Re:Lawmakers slam DOJ prosecution of Swartz as 'ridiculous, ... by krichman on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @03:38AM (#5065971)
> Our fault, not theirs. They really are representing us here.

Why are you blaming the victims? It's not difficult to determine that the current penal system is ridiculous, and unlike us, it's their responsibility to do so. <hyperbole magnitude="a bit"> Instead, they focus on making copyright legislation to support corporate interests. And the courts focus on whether or not the 5th Amendment was a good idea after all. </hyperbole>

I agree with you completely that we should be doing more to advocate for reform, but it is far from being our fault.

Re:Lawmakers slam DOJ prosecution of Swartz as 'ridiculous, ... by pyre on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @11:44PM (#5065333)
I don't know. I think the fact that he killed himself is a very strong message that wouldn't have been attached to movement (by 'us') prior to his death (not that I'm happy it happened).
Re:Lawmakers slam DOJ prosecution of Swartz as 'ridiculous, ... by WhaleBiologist on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @01:07AM (#5065583)
Martyrdom is a hell of a drug.
Re:Lawmakers slam DOJ prosecution of Swartz as 'ridiculous, ... by dromidas on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @09:07PM (#5064691)
I think the counter point would be that if they actually do make positive changes to the laws to reflect their newfound wisdom then perhaps their public pandering will actually be a good thing.

The public just needs to make sure that they do make changes and aren't just happy with them eating crow. Saying shit is broken just to look good does nothing for the people, but if they actually fix shit then they can say whatever they want imo.

Re:Lawmakers slam DOJ prosecution of Swartz as 'ridiculous, ... by jlgreco on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @09:18PM (#5064744)
I don't know if you can really blame congresspeople for being apathetic while Aaron was alive if even HN of all communities largely was as well.
Re:Lawmakers slam DOJ prosecution of Swartz as 'ridiculous, ... by pyre on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @11:50PM (#5065348)
Until action takes place, there's no distinction between political opportunism (i.e. blowing a lot of hot-air at the press to look good and maybe win a few votes) and genuine concern about the state of the law.