Re:Aaron Swartz was 'killed by the government,' father tells...
by politician on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @07:38PM
(#5064224)
Aren't you aware that we already do take into account the mental states of defendants - the mentally challenged, the insane?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Aaron Swartz was 'killed by the government,' father tells...
by anigbrowl on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @07:44PM
(#5064265)
Yes, and one of the ways we do so is by the defense filing a motion to argue that the defendant is unfit to stand trial for the time being. I haven't followed the motion work in the case, so I don't know if his defense team made any such claim. But it seems to be that quite a few people are trying to have it both ways - on the one hand he was too mentally fragile to be put on trial, on the other he wanted his day in court to argue for the right to download freely and so the plea bargain with the mild sentence (which would have been served in some sort of minimum security facility) was an unconscionable deal with the devil.
Re:Aaron Swartz was 'killed by the government,' father tells...
by politician on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @07:57PM
(#5064351)
That is a good argument for why Heymann would not be a contributor. That is, Heymann has clean hands because the defense failed to make the court aware that Swartz was possibly unfit to stand trial. Thank you.
Re:Aaron Swartz was 'killed by the government,' father tells...
by mc32 on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @07:38PM
(#5064228)
In extreme cases, yes. People are put on suicide watches, but the trials proceed. The bar for being considered 'insane' and 'mentally unfit' is very high. You have people who would colloquially be considered 'crazy' go to trial, represent themselves, etc.
Re:Aaron Swartz was 'killed by the government,' father tells...
by politician on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @07:40PM
(#5064239)
But that did not happen here, did it? Does that make Heymann a contributor?
Re:Aaron Swartz was 'killed by the government,' father tells...
by mc32 on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @07:48PM
(#5064288)
I don't think so. It's a really tenous connection. It's like saying me getting on the freeway contributed to an accident which happens 10 minutes behind me. Sure, maybe if I had not gotten on the freeway that would have caused a different pattern of traffic on the freeway so that the accident would not have happened, but in no way would I be a direct contributor.
Re:Aaron Swartz was 'killed by the government,' father tells...
by politician on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @07:53PM
(#5064327)
Would you change your mind if you were warned that by getting on the freeway there stood a serious above average risk of causing a accident?
Re:Aaron Swartz was 'killed by the government,' father tells...
by sethist on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @07:43PM
(#5064258)
In those cases isn't it due to the fact that the defendant is unable to mentally process their crime, trial, or potential punishment?
Re:Aaron Swartz was 'killed by the government,' father tells...
by politician on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @07:51PM
(#5064308)
The fact that the boy is dead is grim proof that he was "unable to mentally process his potential punishment".
Re:Aaron Swartz was 'killed by the government,' father tells...
by sethist on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @08:02PM
(#5064376)
No it isn't. If anything it shows that he didn't want to endure his potential punishment. If he didn't understand the potential punishment there would be no need to commit suicide.
Re:Aaron Swartz was 'killed by the government,' father tells...
by politician on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @08:17PM
(#5064445)
Your statement could be misinterpreted to mean that any rational competent defendant would consider the potential punishment worse than death.
I'm positive that you meant that he understood what 35 years in jail and a felony charge meant and was thus not unfit to stand trial under an insanity claim. That's fair.