Re:Plea Bargaining and Torture in light of the Aaron Swartz ...
by maxerickson on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @10:29PM
(#5065064)
I'm saying if you choose to configure your server to answer a request, you had better not come back later saying you didn't mean to answer that particular request. It's exactly in the spirit of the web, publishing something at a url is a grant of access to whatever was published.
So what was the sentence in question?
That goes entirely against the principles on which activists claim the Web is based on. Instead of a democratic network where anyone with an IP address can fire up an httpd and be (in theory) just as equal as any other DNS entry, you're saying there needs to be technical measures put in place to enforce an "honor code". What's next, DRM on mp3 files?
But either way, they and MIT both took many "meaningful steps" against aaronsw, and he sidestepped every one.
> I don't mean to say that there should be no recourse in situations where intended access is exceeded, I mean that the bar for a 30 year felony needs to be a little higher than "we didn't intend for our system to be accessed in that manner".
Luckily, 30 years wasn't the sentence in question, even with the heavy-handed prosecution in place, and what transpired was more than "our system was accessed once in an unintended fashion". So the bar probably does need to be moved, but it's not as if he simply wandered near the wrong Wifi hotspot and accidentally mirrored a website...