I think that's a false dichotomy. It's possible to make the network and the attached services more resilient to a DoS without making it less open.
Maybe they could, I don't know, filter out requests from certain malicious MAC addresses? Start dropping packets from the wrong IP address? Surely that would suffice, right?
Oh please. Hardened systems and open access are not mutually exclusive. Pretending they are is the domain of untalented admins and those that wish to mislead you on reasoning for policy.
Also, this is MIT, the biggest threats to their network live on campus and are poking around on that network every day.
Or is that the goal? To make MIT stop being so open?