Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go...
by crusso on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @11:31AM
(#5061024)
I recommend that you watch "Waiting for Superman". It focuses on the charter school initiatives across the country and shows that maybe we should be running schools much more like businesses. When you see how poor the options are for many of these inner city kids outside of the limited charter school options - it's heartbreaking.
Just like you'll see recommended on HN, if you're going to fail, fail early and get on with something that has a chance of working. Our government funded education system is a long painful failure that established forces prevent from being scrapped and reinvented.
Teacher competition, I think, would reduce collaboration. Why give your competitor your secrets to success?
Incentive pay? The problem under this idea is that new teachers are often given the most difficult and unruly of students while more experienced teachers get honors classes. I find this odd because the teachers will the best "tools" for dealing with difficult problems are moved away from those problems.
Then again, the problem is that with any idea for reform, there is a list of reasons why it should not or would not work.
I'm a fan of letting students who are not interested in the academics of school work towards trade school and let those who are academically inclined to work towards university. However, a retired college physics professor friend of mine does not like this solution because he would have been tracked towards trade school and never discovered his love for physics.