News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: NixOS, why no init freedom? by davydm on Sunday November 22, 2026 @11:35AM (#50601159)
I use Gentoo, with open-rc, so hear me out:

I far prefer open-rc over systemd, but I've seen a lot, lately, of releases that _rely_ on systemd. People seem to think it's the standard, so that's what people target, instead of trying to make stuff that's init-agnostic. Perhaps that's what's driving it - the things that Gentoo supports in open-rc land are extra work for someone (which I highly appreciate), but at the end of the day, that's often the tightest constraint on a distro: maintainers. It's often just about "who is going to do the work?", followed by "can we make the experience as good as we have it with systemd?". It's a tall order, I think.

I literally switched to Gentoo from some deb-based distro (I forget which: I cut my teeth on debian, used it for years, then internet was fast enough to use something that updates more regularly, so I switched to ubuntu - also, from my home country! - and variants thereafter - some closer to ubuntu (kubuntu, mint), some further away (LMDE), but always deb-based. When systemd just landed, I had so much crap with it - machine would stall at shutdown, services would just die, and where the hell are my logs? (didn't know about journalctl, and anyway, why can't I just have text logs by default?)). At the time, they were the _only_ distro with first-class support that was considered "ready". Devuan was forming, but I had had enough with Poettering's droppings (pulseaudio also died on me - frequently: enough that I wrote a watchdog script for it).

The amount of time it took Devuan to do the switch is indicative of the effort, imo.

There are no comments on this comment yet.