Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go...
by brudgers on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @08:21AM
(#5059917)
The study identifies teachers who are effective against a particular metric. Most identified are likely members of the subset of good teachers. Yet, the three R's as measured by standardized test outcomes are not the only measure of effective education, just one that is cheap to measure.
Dewey believed that the goal of education should be to produce good citizens. Systems with metrics based upon the model of student as consumer are more likely to produce outcomes biased toward producing consumers.
The entire set of good teachers includes those who inspire a lifetime of learning. It includes those who teach kindness, sportsmanship, and good humor. It includes those who teach subjects for which there are few students and in which standardized tests make little sense such as art and shop.
Maybe the study can point us in the right direction. But few districts will bring outside evaluators from Cambridge's famed institutions. Few districts will fund ETS analysis or purchase their tools.
What we are likely to get are processes localized to the political reality on the ground.
Dewey believed that the goal of education should be to produce good citizens. Systems with metrics based upon the model of student as consumer are more likely to produce outcomes biased toward producing consumers.
The entire set of good teachers includes those who inspire a lifetime of learning. It includes those who teach kindness, sportsmanship, and good humor. It includes those who teach subjects for which there are few students and in which standardized tests make little sense such as art and shop.
Maybe the study can point us in the right direction. But few districts will bring outside evaluators from Cambridge's famed institutions. Few districts will fund ETS analysis or purchase their tools.
What we are likely to get are processes localized to the political reality on the ground.