News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by the_bear on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @08:20AM (#5059914)
It's common for people who received good educations to say that test scores aren't an acceptable indication of learning. It's probably true that if you already have an acceptable level of education, test scores shouldn't be too important, but it seems like the people criticizing test scores haven't experienced what education is like for the children being "left behind."

In middle school, the last three weeks of each semester were spent watching movies (the same two or three movies over and over). In high school, I was taught that the big bang theory was when the continents divided. I was taught that the most direct route between two points on the globe is through the north pole. My Spanish and woodworking teachers taught math because they knew that the math teachers weren't doing it.

When you're talking about schools like the ones I went to (which weren't nearly as bad as many other schools in America) I think that test scores are a decent indicator of the education a student is receiving. You're measuring things like "can this kid read English" and "can they multiply two numbers together." Standardized tests are certainly capable of measuring things like that. Testing probably breaks down for measuring intelligence/education as the level of education improves, but I encourage everyone to consider just how dysfunctional many schools are before ignoring testing entirely.

Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by roguecoder on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @08:47AM (#5060033)
Except that even those things don't predict later success. Any kid with a family that can afford books will score higher on "can this kid read English". Any kid who's been drilled can learn to multiply two numbers together. Without cognitive skills behind them, though, those are not useful abilities.

The best predictors of future success are self-control, emotional intelligence and a grasp of functional algebra (which I believe, but don't have evidence to support, is because of the importance of computational and systems-level thinking.) Only one of those, self-control, is even indirectly measured by current standardized tests.

Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by Nitramp on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @09:21AM (#5060182)
> Without cognitive skills behind them, though, [multiplication, reading] are not useful abilities.

Maybe I misunderstand you, but I fail to see how multiplication or reading are not useful skills. Good reading comprehension will help you navigate life in general, which is something lots of people struggle with. Similar for multiplication.

Even if someone is not very intelligent, if he's mastered a basic skill like that, he'll find lots of places to apply it. That's why there's so much emphasis in school on them.

Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by sopooneo on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @10:30AM (#5060536)
From my work teaching I am very skeptical of the notion that it is a family's ability to "afford" books that makes the difference. It is whether the family knows that books are important and chooses to get them and read with their children. While monetary poverty is horrible, it's effect on educational outcome is dwarfed in comparison to cultural dysfunction and despair.
Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by w1ntermute on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @11:15AM (#5060887)
Yeah, the monetary poverty theory doesn't hold up when it comes to the case of poor Asian (or African) immigrants. Although it certainly plays some role when all other things are equal, I think the major issue to be tackled is the glorification of thug life and demonization of education in contemporary African American culture.
Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by roguecoder on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @02:26PM (#5062324)
Sorry, that was unclear: the study I was thinking of specifically looked at giving poor families children's books and founded a measurable improvement in English skills. Of course access to a library that is open when a parent doesn't have to work, the time and energy to read to children and many other factors also play a role in early exposure to literacy.
Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by ims on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @09:05AM (#5060108)
> Any kid with a family that can afford books will score higher on "can this kid read English".

True, but there are also many families that can afford books but don't buy them, instead spending money on other things. Not having books in the house has been shown to correlate with decreased academic success.[1] I'm not saying this isn't a wealth issue, but that probably isn't the only dimension.

[1] http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0276562410...

Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by sp332 on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @09:33AM (#5060241)
I think it's worth emphasizing that the research done in this article doesn't look at kids' absolute test scores, but only the difference between test scores before and after the school year.

Also, my school emphasized self-control, but how do you learn emotional intelligence?

Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by roguecoder on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @02:32PM (#5062373)
While it is a relatively recent topic of interest, surprisingly it doesn't seem particularly difficult to teach. Much of the research is still in the preliminary stages, but one study found persistent improvement after a brief four-session intervention: http://orbi.ulg.ac.be/bitstream/2268/30253/1/Nelis%20PAID%20...

It will take further work to associate learning such skills with the positive outcomes associated with the skills themselves and figure out what the best ways to teach the skills are, but current research is promising.

Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by sp332 on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @02:41PM (#5062445)
Cool, thanks!
Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by tbrownaw on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @11:46AM (#5061141)
I didn't read that as saying that testing can predict (outstanding) success. I read it as saying that testing can detect (outstanding) failure.

If a student does at least moderately well on standardized tests, there's a decent chance they'll do at least moderately well later in life.

If most of a teacher's students flunk completely on the standardized tests, the teacher probably isn't doing a very good job.

Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by lonnyk on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @10:40AM (#5060606)
>Any kid with a family that can afford books will score higher on "can this kid read English".

I don't think this is true. Those who can't afford books can goto the public library and get them.

Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by danielweber on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @11:23AM (#5060960)
Plus, books are really really really cheap. Go to any Goodwill or Salvation Army or Once Upon A Child and you will find gobs and gobs of books at very cheap prices. Yes, even undamaged.

We toss lots of books in the trash in America, not because we hate books, but because we make so many of them and then need to make room for the new books.

"Able to afford books" was once a status symbol. It's not any more.

See also: http://www.npr.org/blogs/monkeysee/2011/10/12/141265066/hard...

Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by infinite8s on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @11:39AM (#5061083)
This was more a correlation than causation (see Freakonomics for a description). Typically, families that can't afford books have other general issues that preclude their children from doing well (for example, they are poor, their parents typically work more than 1 job and can't spend much time with their children, etc).
Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by elemenohpee on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @08:24AM (#5059930)
Where did you go to school? How does this happen?
Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by the_bear on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @08:40AM (#5060006)
I went to the University City School District in St. Louis. It was actually a pretty strange place because it's the main district that Wash U (Washington University in St. Louis) is in, so about 10% of the students are children of (mostly white) professors and other very education-oriented professionals (doctors, lawyers, etc). Because of that, top classes (honors and AP) were actually pretty good. I, and many of my classmates went to Wash U and other top universities.

The rest of the student body was made up of poor, mostly black students who came from families where education wasn't a priority. Every single year I was in high school the state tried to revoke our accreditation and we just barely passed a state audit to keep it. I was a math tutor, and it was common for students to come in who couldn't do basic addition (in high school).

To make matters more confusing, the gap between the good students and the bad was almost entirely caused by economics (wealthier parents resulted in smarter kids, as is normally the case) but because the economic divide was almost identical to the racial divide, many of the educational issues were easily conflated with racial issues. This led to the (mostly black) teachers and administration demonstrating favoritism toward white students, and it also created tremendous social pressure on black students not to try to succeed academically (otherwise you're an oreo).

I wouldn't trade my experience there for anything. I received a pretty good education, and I experienced a part of America that more privileged kids should experience, but most of the students at my school were definitely being left behind.

Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by poppysan on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @10:25AM (#5060504)
I can co-sign for the quality of the district he mentions. My nieces and nephew are there now. It's totally an economic issue. My sister-in-law really does care about the education of her kids and their potential future, but she has to work 2 jobs to barely support them adequately. It's a case of survival knocking education down a notch on the priority scale.
Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by w1ntermute on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @11:17AM (#5060912)
What class were you in to be taught that incorrect stuff from your OP? I can't imagine those professors and doctors would let it slide if their children were being taught such nonsense.
Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by the_bear on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @03:11PM (#5062655)
The honors and AP classes were generally pretty good (in math and science anyway) but those weren't always options. For example, in 10th grade, there wasn't an honors world history class, so I had to take the normal class. That's where I was taught what the big bang theory was. I knew it was wrong and tried to argue, but the teacher was pretty sure she was right. I immediately went to my adviser and got switched to a different teacher, but the rest of the class didn't know any better (many of them probably thought the teacher was right).

As for parents not getting involved, I'm not sure I ever told my parents about that stuff because I thought it was normal. Middle school was by far the worst part of the district, and a few years ago my brother and I were telling my parents stories about how about once per week there were school-wide riots in the lunch room that the FAs (bouncers) couldn't contain and we could do basically whatever we wanted for 30 minutes because of the chaos. It turns out my parents had no idea this was happening (my mom said she wouldn't have let me go back to that school if she'd known). We never told any parents because we thought every school had riots like that.

Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by barik on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @10:32AM (#5060555)
I have no idea how it happens, but I recall having more teachers that I referred to as "Coach" instead of "Mr.", "Ms.", or "Dr." while in middle school and early high school.

I'll add to this since I think these types of stories occurs more often than people think. I went to Baker High School in Mobile, Alabama (that might be your first clue).

In the 8th grade I took a required course called Earth Science, also of course taught by a coach. I recall that the last question of one of the exams was "The Universe was created by _____________". Odd. I thought this was a fairly complex answer for a simple fill in the blank question, especially for tests which were typically always multiple choice or fill in the blank. So I just assumed that the empty space below it (since it was the last question) was for writing a short answer.

So, I did my best to mention the Big Bang Theory and associated information about red shifts and such for scientific evidence. In the end, my answer was about a paragraph long, and I felt really good about my answer.

I did get full credit, but I noticed that other students also got full credit but wrote only in the blank itself. So I checked with the teacher for how I could have been more concise. Turns out that the correct answer that he was looking for was "God".

I guess the question was a simple fill in the blank after all.

Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by w1ntermute on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @11:11AM (#5060850)
Isn't that illegal? Or has that been turned into a states' rights issue and been made legal by the Alabama legislature?
Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by barik on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @11:49AM (#5061162)
I've wondered that myself, particularly in regards to the recent evolution vs. "intelligent design" debates in school as of late. I'd be interested to here what other HN readers think.

This is the most dramatic instance I experienced, but in Honors English we spent at least a week on the Bible, but never any other religious texts. Conveniently, at the same time I had read some vampire fiction by Anne Rice and concluded that it's possible that Satan is actually the hero of the Adam & Eve story. It turns out, however, that this is not a good opinion to express when trying to do well in English in a conservative public state school.

As to Earth Science, I was not penalized for my response; had it been, this would have been clearly objectionable. On the other hand, at the time I did feel that it was unfair in that one could give what I considered a cop-out answer for full credit. It may be a theologically true response, but it does not give us any scientific insight and understanding into our Universe.

Given the two examples above, I'm not really sure. It can certainly be uncomfortable for someone who is brought up as an atheist, but I'm not sure it's outright illegal. And this is where the avenue for standardized testing comes in -- it's not necessarily to demonstrate student learning but perhaps rather to better identify egregious issues in school districts.

Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by w1ntermute on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:12PM (#5061325)
> It can certainly be uncomfortable for someone who is brought up as an atheist, but I'm not sure it's outright illegal.

I'm quite sure it is illegal according to federal law. The question is whether state law trumps this. Because if it does, no doubt Alabama has passed a law making it legal to teach creationism in schools.

Re:Gates Foundation study: We’ve figured out what makes a go... by glenra on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @02:48PM (#5062502)
Even at good schools with non-religious teachers, students are undoubtedly taught lots of information that's false. Teachers are of merely average intelligence and often just don't know that what they're teaching is false.

Which is fine because if the subject matter actually matters, there will be ample chances to relearn it later. Having teachers teach stuff that is wrong is only a big problem if you think teachers need to be infallible. But the fact that teachers can be wrong seems to me one of the more important true things kids learn in school.