News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Impossible to compete with free software by tptacek on Friday March 06, 2009 @04:39PM (#505984)
If a competitor takes your code, modifies it, and resells it as closed source software, you sue and win.

If a competitor takes your code, modifies it, and tries to sell it as a new open source project, nobody cares. It's a fork:

* For better or worse, real customers will stick with the "original brand".

* The fork won't get any of the community support the original did, and will always be out of sync.

* Whatever community forms around the original project will angrily reject the fork.

* Worst of all, any future development your competitor does on the product reverts back to your own code. You have all the structural advantages, as the original project owner. Your competitor is just playing to lose.

It's not like this is a supposition of mine. A great example of a project that executed this business plan: SourceFire/Snort (now a public company). Lots of companies have tried to piggyback on Snort, but for Snort's core customers, nobody has succeeded.

There's no clever algorithmic idea you can "hide" in closed-source code. Copycats are an issue (although far less of one than you think) regardless of your business model. Arbor Networks did all sorts of clever stuff under the hood (we were baselining the Internet backbone, after all), was closed source, and was beseiged by copycats.

Re:Impossible to compete with free software by kragen on Friday March 06, 2009 @07:53PM (#506179)
If a competitor takes your code, modifies it, and resells it as closed source software, you sue and win.

I guess you're talking specifically about GPL-style copyleft, not Apache or BSD licensing?

There's an additional alternative: the competitor takes the code and adds features to it, then sells services on top of it. This is kind of a best-case scenario: you get free R&D.

Re:Impossible to compete with free software by joeyo on Friday March 06, 2009 @08:31PM (#506202)

  * For better or worse, real customers will stick with the
  "original brand".
  * The fork won't get any of the community support the
  original did, and will always be out of sync.
  * Whatever community forms around the original project
  will angrily reject the fork.
I don't believe this is always true--usually the superior* fork wins out. Take Firefox or xorg. Both of them effectively replaced the projects from which they came.

* Where superior here means technically, or aesthetically or friendlier to contributers or whatever.

Re:Impossible to compete with free software by tptacek on Friday March 06, 2009 @09:35PM (#506234)
Got an example where a commercial product usurped another commercial product's open source project?
Re:Impossible to compete with free software by critic on Sunday March 08, 2009 @08:34PM (#507721)
Few commercial projects will open source their code, unless they already have reasons to believe that they can't be usurped for one reason or another.
Re:Impossible to compete with free software by yason on Saturday March 07, 2009 @02:33AM (#506358)
On a market a single law applies: the product that is better marketed wins out.

Eventhough I'd love to see it otherwise, any aesthetical or technical superiority would need to come in enormous figures to even challenge the position of the market leader. For a unsurprising and worn example, look at Microsoft.

On the other hand, if some company takes your code and does better both in marketing and technical aspects, you _should_ lose! The better product is better for everyone in the developer/user base, including you. The community and users don't lose anything -- instead they gain! You do gain as well because you can incorporate the other company's changes back to your own codebase -- of course you did license the software under GPL.