News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In the Wake of Aaron Swartz's Death, Let's Fix Draconian ... by eru on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @01:54AM (#5059086)
Could you elaborate on what you mean by substantive vs procedural?
Re:In the Wake of Aaron Swartz's Death, Let's Fix Draconian ... by anigbrowl on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @03:35AM (#5059304)
Very, very briefly: Substantive is the what, procedural is the how. In Aaron Swartz's case the substantive argument is that copying academic journal articles shouldn't be a prosecutable crime in the first place, but at worst a civil tort. The procedural argument is that Swartz went about his activities in a demonstrably illegal fashion and was arrested pursuant to a properly issued warrant. Is the law stupid? Maybe, but that's what it says and we're just following it as written. Now in a civil law country (where legislative text >> precedent) you'll often enjoy all sorts of substantive protections that you wouldn't have in the US, but if you did break a law then you probably won't be able to argue your way out on technicalities like whether the police search was legal or you were read your rights correctly.

The constitution doesn't give you a whole lot of rights, but rather imposes a variety of limitations upon the government. If someone in government can find a hole in those limitations, then there isn't a whole lot you can do about it, at least in the short term. Look at the drug laws; Congress certainly seems to be within its rights to ban possession of certain substances, and there's no substantive right to say you have jurisdiction over what you put in your own body. Another famous legal example is the Dredd Scott case; the Supreme Court of the day said that a law law which gave a slave called Dredd Scott his freedom was an unconstitutional infringement of his owner's property rights (procedural argument). Now we consider the whole notion of people being property invalid (substantive) so even the most logically watertight contract in which someone agrees to be the property of someone else is void and unenforceable. Now, contrast the familiar language of the US constitution with things like the UN declaration of human rights, which imposes very few strictures on how governments go about governing, but has a great deal to say about how people should be treated and is much more like the Declaration of Independence than the Constitution (http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr/index.shtml).

This is a complex philosophical issue at the heart of legal theory and hard to sketch out in only a few sentences. Think of the above as an impressionistic sketch rather than a systematic description.

Re:In the Wake of Aaron Swartz's Death, Let's Fix Draconian ... by eru on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @06:12AM (#5059617)
Thanks. That reminds me of a German book on law that I read, that briefly sketched how German law went from procedural to rights and obligations (i.e. substantive, if I get it right).

Just to check my understanding: Roman law was mostly procedural, wasn't it?