Re:In the Wake of Aaron Swartz's Death, Let's Fix Draconian ...
by anigbrowl on Monday January 14, 2013 @10:19PM
(#5058401)
There should also be a push for better use of discretion and 'common sense' from the US judiciary.
As a general matter (IOW I haven't analyzed the CFAA in this light) the judicary only has as much discretion as the legislature grants it. Populist legislators do not like the idea of an independent judiciary and frequently attempt to exclude legislative clauses from judicial review - which attempts often fail, but at considerably increased political cost to the judiciary. I'm personally biased, but it's worth considering that there are a lot more constitutional constraints on the executive and legislative branches than upon the judicial. 'Judicial activism' is the buffer on which many a judicial career has been halted, no matter how well-founded the decision it is applied to.
As a general matter (IOW I haven't analyzed the CFAA in this light) the judicary only has as much discretion as the legislature grants it. Populist legislators do not like the idea of an independent judiciary and frequently attempt to exclude legislative clauses from judicial review - which attempts often fail, but at considerably increased political cost to the judiciary. I'm personally biased, but it's worth considering that there are a lot more constitutional constraints on the executive and legislative branches than upon the judicial. 'Judicial activism' is the buffer on which many a judicial career has been halted, no matter how well-founded the decision it is applied to.