You're conflating 'groupthink' and 'magical thinking'.
An arbitrary contrarian idea is not evidence of 'groupthink'
'Groupthink' is common - more common that not.
The 'Gell-Mann Amnesia effect' alludes to this - whenever someone with expertise reads about something in the press related to their expertise - they realize 'the media has it wrong' - but they continue to 'trust the media' on all other matters.
That's nuanced, but observable.
But in most cases - public narratives or common misconceptions are easily remedied with a few basic facts.
A military expert could quickly dispell misconceptions about 'how the war in Iran is actually going'.
In the case of AI - it's true that we probably have a common misunderstanding or intuition for how it works.
That does not mean the OPs imperious claim has any validity.
LLM AI is absolutely a communications technology. Every single aspect of understanding them and understanding how to use them is a communications problem. Yet, you'll argue that.
The comprehension exhibited by LLM AI is not comprehension, it is pattern recognition. That subtle distinction is critical. Comprehension is the creation and operation of virtual systems within the comprehending mind for the purpose of validating an observation for fraud, for plausibility and therefore continued safely, and for validating exploratory concepts. There is no statistical reply generation there would be something else entirely that is not statistical calculus driven.
What a shameful lack of self awareness for someone who is making 'magical claims' - and who cannot express their ideas; your closing paragraph is gibberish.
You're the one making incredulous claims, not me.
Anyone claiming to have some obvious purview that literally millions of other people working intimately with the subject cannot perceive is by definition making a dubious claim ... which is fine ... so long as it's backed up by some kind of logical assertion or evidence, which you have not provided.
1) "Every single aspect of understanding them and understanding how to use them is a communications problem."
This is not a reasonable claim.
2) "Pattern recognition is not comprehension"
Is a reasonable claim - and very common perspective.
It's at the core of the debate surrounding AI, not some 'specific insight' that is somehow rare.
It's literally what everyone is talking about.
3) "There is no statistical reply generation there would be something else entirely that is not statistical calculus driven."
That is not even English, it makes no sense - it reads like an LLM with severely corrupted context.
4) As to the actual argument: Humans are ultimately biological 'neural networks' it could very well be that our reasoning is effectively a form of pattern recognition.
The underlying architecture of Le Cun's JEPA architecture give a strong hint to that - they have a layer of abstraction above tokenisation wherein the model can essentially 'reason' in a way that may be more familiar than the kinds of synthetic 'token reasoning' we seen in LLM architectures today.
So you're the genius that has figured it all out, and the entire world is wrong?
It's far more likely you are wrong.
Yes - there is absolutely reason to question AGI, and the way in which we understand AI popularly is 'wrong' - but - the better ways for understanding it are not arcane. In fact, you'd be able to get most people to agee with the less popular but 'more valid' description with ease.
"AI is a means of communication not automation" is a completely contrarian take - not some kind of 'obviously valid' perspective,
"GI requires artificial comprehension which is a science that humanity does not have. " - LLMs exhibit artificial comprehension already - albeit on a very rudimentary scale. It's very reasonable to suggest that they are 'inherently limited' but that's a different argument.