Re:What Comes After AGI?
by Silamoth on Friday November 20, 2026 @10:26AM
(#50576058)
Your first paragraphs echo my thoughts very closely. I’m not that old. But just a few years ago, everyone technical knew “AI” was really just a buzzword. Sure, you might tell investors or grant funders that you’re using “AI” to solve a problem because that sounded fancy and impressive. But whatever you were doing was fancy math and statistical modeling. Neural networks were loosely inspired by brains, but they’re really just fancy math.
The term AGI arose to distinguish these buzzword/lay uses of “AI” from ‘actual’ intelligence. Even that notion was always ill-defined and really a philosophical problem as much as a technical one. But the vision was always mimicking humans or smarter. Not just in fact recall. Not just in reading faster than humans. But logical and emotional intelligence on the level of human geniuses, accelerated by computation. Think Jarvis in Iron Man, Data in Star Trek, or C-3PO in Star Wars. You should be able to hold a natural conversation with an actual AI. You should be able to trust it to accomplish essentially any task (maybe with some instruction, like a human). It should be able to learn.
Over the last couple years, though, these tech bros seem to have redefined AI and AGI to mean LLMs - obviously because it benefits them. They are a far cry from anything described before as genuinely real AI - or AGI. I understand how nontechnical laypeople can be confused. But technical people should know better. And yet so many have fallen for the propaganda, even here on HN.
Note: This is largely orthogonal to whether or not LLMs are a useful tool
The term AGI arose to distinguish these buzzword/lay uses of “AI” from ‘actual’ intelligence. Even that notion was always ill-defined and really a philosophical problem as much as a technical one. But the vision was always mimicking humans or smarter. Not just in fact recall. Not just in reading faster than humans. But logical and emotional intelligence on the level of human geniuses, accelerated by computation. Think Jarvis in Iron Man, Data in Star Trek, or C-3PO in Star Wars. You should be able to hold a natural conversation with an actual AI. You should be able to trust it to accomplish essentially any task (maybe with some instruction, like a human). It should be able to learn.
Over the last couple years, though, these tech bros seem to have redefined AI and AGI to mean LLMs - obviously because it benefits them. They are a far cry from anything described before as genuinely real AI - or AGI. I understand how nontechnical laypeople can be confused. But technical people should know better. And yet so many have fallen for the propaganda, even here on HN.
Note: This is largely orthogonal to whether or not LLMs are a useful tool