News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In the Wake of Aaron Swartz's Death, Let's Fix Draconian ... by AnthonyMouse on Monday January 14, 2013 @07:08PM (#5057560)
>My point is this: of necessity, most laws are broad and vague, and it relies on judges to build the necessary case law to interpret it.

I don't think that is a necessity at all. What it is is a trade off. Compare tax law with antitrust law. There is relatively little vagueness in tax law, which is why the statutes are so verbose (or vice versa). Antitrust is technically "statutory" in that Congress passed the Sherman and Clayton antitrust acts etc., but the statutes are very short and very broad and their meaning has been defined almost entirely by the courts.

Each has advantages and disadvantages, but going too far in either direction is disastrous. (Which is why both tax and antitrust are a huge mess.) And that's where we are with the CFAA. The statute doesn't designate any particular harm you have to be aiming to cause, it just says "access without authorization -> felony conviction" regardless of whether you stole anything or hurt anyone or intended anything malicious, etc. It encourages courts and juries to think in terms of whether you violated the letter of the statute rather than whether you did anything specifically objectionable, and assume that any such violation must be a terrible crime worthy of that level of penalty without requiring any evidence that the circumstances of the specific case justify that outcome.

I honestly think we could repeal it entirely without any negative consequences following, because the actually objectionable things that people can do after they access a computer without authorization would still be separately illegal.

>'computer law' will always be 10 steps behind the technology.

I'm not at all sure that this is true. Most "computer law" is redundant garbage: There are laws against fraud, espionage, copyright infringement, etc. Those laws don't inherently become obsolete just because you add "on a computer" to it. Perhaps they need to be adjusted in certain ways -- often as a result of economic changes brought about by technology -- but that is no excuse for having a duplicate set of expansive, poorly drafted laws with extraordinary penalties that aim to serve substantially the same purposes as those that have been time tested over hundreds of years.

There are no comments on this comment yet.