Re:In the Wake of Aaron Swartz's Death, Let's Fix Draconian ...
by AnthonyMouse on Monday January 14, 2013 @06:49PM
(#5057480)
I've never liked this argument. "Fuzzy" always helps prosecutors (unless the defense can argue that it's so fuzzy it's unconstitutional, which is pretty hard), because the prosecutor gets to choose who goes to court in criminal cases of first impression. They find someone with insufficient resources to mount a vigorous defense who happens to be wildly unsympathetic and the judge and the jury will make the contortions necessary to put them in prison -- and then that precedent sets the stage for the next prosecution.
Make the law clear and some defendant will get off on a technicality, but only once, then you fix the loophole. Over time the law evolves to more accurately reflect congressional intent as they pass patches to fix bugs, instead of leaving it to the courts and the biases (like prosecutors choosing who to prosecute when they want a precedent) that come along with that.
Make the law clear and some defendant will get off on a technicality, but only once, then you fix the loophole. Over time the law evolves to more accurately reflect congressional intent as they pass patches to fix bugs, instead of leaving it to the courts and the biases (like prosecutors choosing who to prosecute when they want a precedent) that come along with that.