News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to CAD Almost Anything by zonkerdonker on Friday November 20, 2026 @12:48AM (#50570642)
Ill take a shot at answering. Im also an ME at a very AI forward company.

The hard part of mechanical design isn't really the CAD. Ask any long time professional mechanical design engineer, and I can almost guaruntee you that they will tell you that they can CAD up a design faster than they can think it. There are AI tools that can absolutely help with some of the more tedious tasks in the process (2D specification and tolerancing, part families and variants, texture tables etc). The difficult part of the job is synthesizing the massive number of variables and requirements and finding an optimal solution. Current models have been trained on all sorts of 3D, not just functional mechanical designs. AI doesnt know that a MIM steel part from vendor X can have a thinner wall thickness compared to a diecast steel part from vendor y, which would mean x grams of weight saving which cpuld be used to shore up a weak area on the other side of the part. It doesnt know that a sharp corner near an injection gate can cause porosity in some materials. It's not good at designing strong parts in general. It doesnt know that the ID team wants a specific surface on an user-facing surface which requires draft angle minimums relative to the mold parting direction. And, if you take the time to gather all that data and then type it all out for a model, you would spend twice as long writing everything down in plain language as it would take to just CAD it up yourself.

It can take months to gather all of these requirements piece by piece from all teams across the org (rf design, thermal, structural and FEA, aerodynamics, environmental ratings, safety, etc etc), and as the design matures things change as well.

For professionals with training in the tools, CAD as it is now is already the most optimal method of getting a design into the computer, and that was never really the hardest part of the process anyway.

Re:How to CAD Almost Anything by YuechenLi on Friday November 20, 2026 @03:10AM (#50571617)
So... many of these are just DFM checks, right? Requirement checks like draft angle minimum and refusal of sharp angles near gates can be enforced programmatically during build time, and in terms of strength of material those can be checked via fast FEA. You are correct that modeling is never the hard part and everything else that happens after modeling is, and I do agree with you that the current AI CAD is insufficient on that front because they overfocus on the modeling portion.
Re:How to CAD Almost Anything by breakfast_burri on Friday November 20, 2026 @05:04AM (#50572529)
I’d also add that a truly parametric cad model requires either a mystical level of precognition or constantly evaluating the function of the part and what is likely to change in each design step. AI struggles with functional evaluation (especially with moving components) and guessing what might be changed in the future.
Re:How to CAD Almost Anything by zonkerdonker on Friday November 20, 2026 @11:09AM (#50576904)
My examples were there, sure. But they are "just DFM checks" if you know what manufacturing process is required for the part. Knowing that means knowing volumes, cost targets, part requirments, etc. Which again, is the hard part.