The enslaving part I only added to make very clear that the "a human does it" / "a machine does it" analogy breaks down, and we only disagree about exactly where it first starts breaking down.
When we talk about a person learning/recreating stuff they learned from, the person themselves is who we are holding responsible. But a machine is not guilty of anything. It is owned and wielded by a person or more likely a company. It is what that company does that may be unethical.
This goes right to your person-employed-by-company example, I do think the company is acting immorally by gathering up and feeding all that copyrighted data to their superhuman employee, knowing perfectly well that what they are selling their customers is the employee's mimicry of it. It wouldn't be illegal, but then, we don't have the precedent for it since the superhuman-mimicry biotech doesn't exist.
Like I said in my other response, there's always going to be arbitrary differences between people and technology and if you pick some random difference you could try to make an issue with that, but that difference is not what's at hand. It's not about the fact that technology is a choice and people don't. (Which is where I think you'r getting this slavery thing from?) Of course it would be unethical and immoral and should be illegal for you to enslave someone. But that's not the question we're trying to answer today.
What we're talking about today is the copyright infringement of it all. So let's take slavery out of it.
Let's say this person simply worked at a company where they viewed millions of copyrighted works and created new works for the company's customers on demand.
What would be unethical or illegal or immoral about that?
Even if they occasionally reproduced an entire copyrighted work, I could grant that that would be an issue, and shouldn't be allowed under current law, and action could be taken. But I couldn't agree that their mere ability to do this, or the fact that they do this occasionally, should mean it was illegal for them to do the learning and training in the first place.
> Basically, the same rules I apply to any other person today. Do you apply all of these rules to machines, too, or only some of them? I don't apply all of these rules to machines. Like you said, my reason is just "Well they're people, not machines". I accept that. What about you?
I think it depends on the question at hand, not on fundamental differences between man and machine. Of course man has choice and freedom and machines don't, and that's fine. Therefore I don't think I wouldn't compare using a machine to slavery just because you don't have to pay a machine and have to pay a man.
Any analogy has some differences that simply don't translate or hold up. To me I'd just like to focus on the relevant parts of the analogy.
When it comes to laws, I don't see the point in making laws that apply to machines but don't apply to humans doing the same thing.
For example, I can understand not allowing self-driving cars by default, because humans require licenses and training and are subject to jail time for misbehavior, whereas self-driving cards are fundamentally unable to go through the same processes and be held accountable, so society needs time to adjust.
I can understanding allowing human telemarketers but not allowing robocall telemarketers, because the experience of talking to a human is fundamentally difference than the experience of talking to a robot, and it's a human on the other line who has to deal with the robot.
But I couldn't understand, say, allowing humans to calculate numbers, but not allowing spreadsheets or calculators to do it. Sure, they're advantageous. Sure, they put people out of business. (Famously, "calculator" used to be the name of a job, not a device. RIP.) But it's not directly making anyone's lives worse, outside of being outcompeted in the market, which imo is fair and overall beneficial to society.
But I can't understand allowing humans to learn so they can acquire general intelligence, but (imo) abusing copyright law to say that robots aren't allowed to learn, because they're too good at it and (once again) outcompete some jobs or roles in the market.