While this might be true in theory, literally nowhere in the US is anywhere near the upper bound. SF and other bay area municipalities could enact policy tomorrow that legalizes a 5x theoretical housing capacity increase, legalizing housing that is currently illegal to build, on lots that are already developed, not clearing any additional land, and not requiring any tall towers to be built, just modest midrise development.
The other point I'd make is that while the core desirable areas will remain expensive, by increasing capacity across the board, people will be able to live closer to those super desirable areas than they currently can afford to. I don't need to live right next to my job. But if the municipalities in this metropolitan area increased housing capacity by even like 20%, people who currently can only afford to live farther from work, will be able to move closer to work, and achieve shorter commutes and travel times for leisure activities.
Measure Tokyo's 23 wards San Francisco
----------------------- -------------------- --------------------
Land area (sq mi) 242.3 46.9
Land area (sq km) 627.5 121.5
Population 9,983,365 (Oct 2026) 826,079 (Jul 2025)
Density (people/sq mi) 41,200 17,600
Density (people/sq km) 15,900 6,800
Housing price benchmark $809,000 (¥129.4M) $1.66M
Of course, SF can't grow outward, but the population density of Tokyo is much higher.Look at all the buildings around Central Park in Manhattan. Now look at the area around Golden Gate Park for a comparison.
You want them near a rail or tube station so people can commute without cars. They also allow preservation of local green spaces.
Yes supply and demand matter and increasing some supply will have some lowering effect, just like incoming billions of dollars worth of extra demand will do the opposite. There's a real debate to be had about how and how much to build, and how to weight the different tradeoffs. But none of the loud voices on either side of the YIMBY/NIMBY divide care about any of that.
The YIMBY message is always "Build more, problem solved EZPZ. Anyone talking about tradeoffs is a liar or an idiot.", with equally unreasonable people pushing back the other way.
I wish HN could be a place with more nuanced discussion, but posts like this always get upvoted to the top.