Re:Anthropic hits $2T in Nasdaq debut
by ordu on Thursday November 19, 2026 @05:10PM
(#50567166)
> Using the word theft to describe what's going on here, as OP does, is making a moral claim of equivalence, not a legal claim.
Exactly. But the thing is, if you do moral claims in this form, you open yourself for rhetoric of pedants, and then spend all your free time debating the meaning of words instead of talking about things that really matter. People opposing your views would use this rhetoric when they have no better arguments, passing-by pedants would be compelled to debate words with you. (Like I being highly interested in rhetoric techniques can't miss such an opportunity to add my 5 cents, which are technically off topic of your discussion)
> I'd argue that it's also maybe missing the point.
Yes, and no. The statement is ambiguous it can be understand in different ways. If you expect your opponent to use rhetorical techniques against you (maybe unconsciously, rhetoric techniques are double edged and they can posing the thinking of the user), you'd better don't let them do it. It is much easy to handle ambiguity when it starts, then to keep it in mind through all the discussion until it starts deform the logic of argument and then interrupt your opponent, explain the ambiguity, remind them how it came into the discussions and how it developed since then, and why it was not important before and why it is important now.
You see, it is possible that the person who uses "theft" is missing the point. And maybe they do it deliberately to muddle the water.
Using "theft" is good if you are a politic and target your speeches at huge masses of uneducated peasants (they would understand your words as "theft"="copyright infringement" but it kinda not your fault, right?), or if you are talking with people who agree with you already (even if they notice a trick, they would agree with it). If you want a honest debate you'd better make your moral claim explicitly, though I prefer to avoid moral claims completely: if you think a bit, you can replace moral references with references to what is good for a society. Like Max Weber did with Protestantism virtues.
Exactly. But the thing is, if you do moral claims in this form, you open yourself for rhetoric of pedants, and then spend all your free time debating the meaning of words instead of talking about things that really matter. People opposing your views would use this rhetoric when they have no better arguments, passing-by pedants would be compelled to debate words with you. (Like I being highly interested in rhetoric techniques can't miss such an opportunity to add my 5 cents, which are technically off topic of your discussion)
> I'd argue that it's also maybe missing the point.
Yes, and no. The statement is ambiguous it can be understand in different ways. If you expect your opponent to use rhetorical techniques against you (maybe unconsciously, rhetoric techniques are double edged and they can posing the thinking of the user), you'd better don't let them do it. It is much easy to handle ambiguity when it starts, then to keep it in mind through all the discussion until it starts deform the logic of argument and then interrupt your opponent, explain the ambiguity, remind them how it came into the discussions and how it developed since then, and why it was not important before and why it is important now.
You see, it is possible that the person who uses "theft" is missing the point. And maybe they do it deliberately to muddle the water.
Using "theft" is good if you are a politic and target your speeches at huge masses of uneducated peasants (they would understand your words as "theft"="copyright infringement" but it kinda not your fault, right?), or if you are talking with people who agree with you already (even if they notice a trick, they would agree with it). If you want a honest debate you'd better make your moral claim explicitly, though I prefer to avoid moral claims completely: if you think a bit, you can replace moral references with references to what is good for a society. Like Max Weber did with Protestantism virtues.