Not that I feel they should be forced to take traffic that they don't want-- but if they're going to use regulatory capture to restrict competition that (at the very least!) would be a hard requirement.
Anthropic alone may not be as powerful as AT&T in its heyday, but certainly the major AI labs collectively are, on anything they manage to coordinate on.
> I don't think AT&T had detailed dossiers on the most personal thoughts of tens of millions of Americans, including the families of politicians, or the opportunity to subtly slant search engine results
Controlling the communication infrastructure for the entire nation absolutely is a powerful position. And regulation is the reason that power isn't abused.
They certainly have the text message logs of these people, and have the power and legal mandate to wiretap them on demand. ISPs also have traffic logs of all the internet activity individuals take over their network. They also have the location of most people, through their phones as well.
ISPs could absolutely influence which websites and businesses get traffic and don't and its regulation that kept them from wielding it. ISPs have a long-tail of crappy internet businesses and ad networks they had once been building out. Just because Verizon buying Yahoo didn't save it from Google doesn't mean it isn't a (failed) vertical move.
ISPs didn't have the speed and ferocity of AI investments, but they've also had 100 years to get it going and start their buildout. And of course, over those 100 years, we added regulations.
Also, ISPs are absolutely in positions to verticalize their customers, and you can see that throughout history, and see the history of regulation interfering with that.
(I’m not talking about explicit anti-discrimination laws like race/gender, but other “no preference for some customers if you sell the product at all”)