News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How and why the US Justice Department over-prosecutes by btilly on Monday January 14, 2013 @03:10PM (#5056339)
...the system, and more specifically the laws, are the problem.

Not "more specifically", the right word is "including". And the system includes a lot of other broken things.

Such as the way that prosecutors habitually overreach. And no, they don't "have to" do that. They have discretion, but don't get ahead in their jobs unless they do overreach.

So yes, the laws need improvement. But so do prosecutors.

Lawyers have feelings, too. Ortiz almost certainly went into the prosecutor's office to do good, to see justice done and to protect the innocent.

I believe this to be true.

I also believe that Ortiz completely lost track of that, and has become something that she hopefully would have hated when she was younger. Unfortunately for Ortiz, I further believe that having her bear real consequences for having lost her moral compass and justifying her actions with "that's just my job" would be a very useful step on the path to fixing the broken prosecutorial culture that lead to Aaron's suicide.

She will spend the rest of her career second guessing herself with every defendant--both the defendants like Swartz and the murderers and drug dealers that form the rest of her caseload.

Yes, she likely will. Furthermore this is probably not the first tragedy she's been involved with, nor is it likely to be her last if she continues. However her very success in the broken system she's in is direct evidence that this incentive is not enough to get her - or other successful prosecutors - to behave in a humane fashion to those she opposes. Therefore the fact that she feels unhappy about the result is clearly insufficient deterrence.

There are no comments on this comment yet.