Re:Frame – 31.5" color ePaper display
by aidenn0 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @09:57PM
(#50555503)
> I question the logic of refusing to do business with somebody because they have notions that you disagree with morally. It seems to say that people with the wrong moral ideas* should be punished...
Statement A: "There are some specific moral ideas I think are so repugnant that I'm not going to intentionally give money to businesses run by people who hold them"
Statement B: "I refuse to do business with anybody who has wrong moral ideas"
Statement A and Statement B are not equivalent. Demonstrating that Statement B is absurd does nothing to refute Statement A.
> I guess another possibility is that you hope to send a message by reducing their sales, and letting them know that the reason is their bad morals. But then what you're hoping is that they say "Hmm, my profits are down, and the reason is my moral principles. Therefore I will change my principles, for money!". That is, you hope they become unprincipled. Is that really an improvement?
From a deontological point of view, one may merely desire to right action without hoping that any specific external change happens. Direct financial support of an individual that you believe may plan to put the money towards serious immoral use can be considered indirect participation in their immoral actions.
From a consequentialism point of view: Talk is cheap. The cost of taking an action can communicate that one cares. Granted, "not buying a gadget I think is cool" is a rather small cost, but the principle is the same. People are social creatures and such signals will affect the thoughts and actions of those around you.
Statement A: "There are some specific moral ideas I think are so repugnant that I'm not going to intentionally give money to businesses run by people who hold them"
Statement B: "I refuse to do business with anybody who has wrong moral ideas"
Statement A and Statement B are not equivalent. Demonstrating that Statement B is absurd does nothing to refute Statement A.
> I guess another possibility is that you hope to send a message by reducing their sales, and letting them know that the reason is their bad morals. But then what you're hoping is that they say "Hmm, my profits are down, and the reason is my moral principles. Therefore I will change my principles, for money!". That is, you hope they become unprincipled. Is that really an improvement?
From a deontological point of view, one may merely desire to right action without hoping that any specific external change happens. Direct financial support of an individual that you believe may plan to put the money towards serious immoral use can be considered indirect participation in their immoral actions.
From a consequentialism point of view: Talk is cheap. The cost of taking an action can communicate that one cares. Granted, "not buying a gadget I think is cool" is a rather small cost, but the principle is the same. People are social creatures and such signals will affect the thoughts and actions of those around you.