News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When Free Software Isn't Free Enough by saint-evan on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:24PM (#50554886)
I honestly think the author of this article doesn't really consider the value of ideological interoperability. In real life, sometimes maintaining a narrow mandate is itself an ethical decision ESPECIALLY when that mandate allows people with incompatible worldviews to cooperate.

>Software has effects beyond the machine. Systems that decide who gets a loan, a job, or bail are freedom issues, whether or not the license is permissive.»

Hang on to that a second, I'll come around to it.

Consider the single responsibility principle... OSS projects are organized around software freedoms as a well defined set of commitments, allowing contributors to disagree about almost everything else while still cooperating toward those SPECIFIC founding commitments. In daily life, when collaboratively making decisions other people have to live with, I think the narrower the shared commitment, the broader the range of people who can cooperate under it.

The moment you decide to step outside your founding ideology and take on more ethical commitments, you're now attempting to make broader decisions about which other ideologies are morally|ethically correct, creating new reasons for disagreement and potentially new reasons to exclude contributors. Today it's AI-assisted code, tomorrow it's defense employees and then maybe whether corporate sponsorship matches the project's values.

Really, it's easy to see how this causes fragmentation because there isn't a principled stopping point once the project's mandate becomes doing what is ethically right rather than protecting a particular set of freedoms.

I posit that it's COMPLETELY okay to refuse to take a stance on subjects that seem to sit outside the ethics of a project's purpose. There should be a clear delineation between an individual's ethical convictions and making those convictions binding on the group. It's a really blurry line especially since additional ethical positions can seem perfectly reasonable in isolation but collectively just add more friction to cooperation.

It's not the responsibility of the group to take a stance on every moral dilemma separate from its founding ethical stance unless it's existential to that ideology or necessary to fulfill, protect, or practically sustain the original mandate. In this case, I don't think it is.

And tbh, I'd expect leaders of OSS projects to respect the moral agency of contributors by declining to exercise moral authority over questions the group never collectively agreed to delegate to them.

Following that, I sincerely believe that code is absolutely all that matters but this is real life and abstractions can absolutely be leaky. Software really does have an effect beyond the machine. That might seem like an "aha, you see?" scenario but not really...

All that matters is code but code is also, at its most fundamental level, intention. The decision of what to build is actually the most tangible expression of a project's ethical purpose, even more so than whatever its founding principles say. The purpose of a system, after all, is what it does, not what it claims to do.

The code is the vehicle through which a project's particular vision of how the world ought to be is brought into existence. The software's effects beyond the machine are ergo not some separate ethical dimension the project has failed to consider, they're precisely why the project exists in the first place. The movement has already chosen the change it wants to effect in the world, and the software it produces is how it pursues that change.

So the project's ethical commitments are already embedded in the work itself, in what it chooses to build, what it chooses not to build, and the freedoms its software is designed to protect. Its moral direction is expressed through action.

I sincerely don't think that every moral issue connected to software must become part of the project's mandate. The real question is whether that issue materially bears on the particular change the project exists to bring about.

Even for individuals, it's never a good idea to attempt to have an opinion on everything. Sometimes, the most meaningful expression of value is to remain relentlessly focused on the one thing you're trying to accomplish.

There are no comments on this comment yet.