News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: BookTurf, college textbook marketplace by minimaxir on Monday January 14, 2013 @10:46AM (#5055065)
I've seen these type of startups (Book P2P) pop up every semester when I was in college, and I have a genuine question: are these kinds of startups actually sustainable?

a) both supply and demand are seasonal (very, very few people trade books in the middle of a semester)

b) Amazon's/Chegg's prices for college textbooks are good enough that they can be purchased and later resold back to them for a decent amount of money, which can outweigh the inconveince factor of scouring a book-trading service for that one book you need. (and as a college student, you need all the time you can get)

c) Chicken-and-egg problem taken to the extreme. No one buys books until there are sellers, no one sells books until there are buyers.

Re:Show HN: BookTurf, college textbook marketplace by okhudeira on Monday January 14, 2013 @11:19AM (#5055219)
This is a common startup idea with many attempts at solving the problem. Is it sustainable? Maybe as a side venture.

a) Agreed.

b) "good enough" is subjective. College students have very low budgets: if I can get it for cheaper, I'll try and keep trying.

c) Absolutely the toughest nut to crack.

Re:Show HN: BookTurf, college textbook marketplace by andreasklinger on Monday January 14, 2013 @01:07PM (#5055740)
Ad C) double-in on the "Ask your friends"

* Add a fb share button

* Give people the url to share in fb groups

* Fix the tweet button not to have the @bookturf in the beginning of the tweet but in the end

Ad-2 c) You could niche on a few colleges to begin with. Look for fb groups that are already handling this topic.