Re:Deutsche Bank
by dcrazy on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @11:29AM
(#50548318)
Is it “judging a book by its cover” to be vigilant for rhetorical tricks that attempt to dress up speculation as proof? That sounds like an important learned reflex in today’s media landscape.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Deutsche Bank
by avidruntime on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @11:34AM
(#50548398)
No one gave a catch all rule and you are without standing to suggest the reporting here is "dress[ed] up speculation." Why?
I made no such accusation. I said the OP was demonstrating vigilance against such rhetorical tricks. You see 100 nothingburgers dressed up in Fox News-style drama, you start to get cautious about the tone.
It was new when Wikileaks did it the first time.
Re:Deutsche Bank
by avidruntime on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @11:39AM
(#50548463)
I don't see how hand waving the articles due to a design philosophy disagreement amounts to "vigilance" and I don't see any justification to suggest there's rhetorical tricks. Such bad faith assumptions always follow MSM on HN, yet if this were presented as a fellow-valley blog post written in first person POV with some bespoke css slapped on a static page generator I wouldn't be so sure that you'd show up to argue these generic hypotheticals.
I didn’t hand wave a damn thing.
And you are assuming the exact opposite of my biases.
Re:Deutsche Bank
by avidruntime on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @12:33PM
(#50549290)
I never displayed any biases in my calling out baseless criticism. And you can see I was correct as the OP I responded to pivoted his rationalization before giving up without any justification wrt article content.
If the article(s) are garbage then by all means, tell us. But in doing so, if you neglect to criticize it on its merits in a public forum, don't be surprised that someone responds to the distraction.
Are you not also sick of this disease of wanting to be part of a conversation without doing the homework?
> Are you not also sick of this disease of wanting to be part of a conversation without doing the homework?
Physician, heal thyself. Anyone who reads these threads carefully will see a rather large gap between what you have preached and what you have practiced.
Re:Deutsche Bank
by avidruntime on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @01:42PM
(#50550306)
Then I look forward to the opportunity to face that criticism.