Re:Can Peer Review Survive AI-Generated Text? [pdf]
by robwwilliams on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @10:56AM
(#50547870)
You are probably responding to the ASI component. Today Opus 5.5 is definitely better at reviewing complex papers and grant applications in my field (neurogenetics and geroscience) than most human reviewers. It is already “no contest” in my experience.
The trouble is that most researchers at frontier labs were AGI/ASI/RSI-pilled a long time ago, likely when it was a distinctly minority position. It's part of their worldview, and as human beings, they're unlikely to say that it's not happening without very strong evidence that it's not happening.
The catch is that such evidence has not really appeared! The trends might just keep going! But I am skeptical that the predictions of the frontier lab folks are really valuable beyond the couple-of-months look into the future that their existing internal models provide.