News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Talos Linux by cwiggs on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @09:45AM (#50546936)
I was lucky enough to run Talos Linux for our k8s cluster for various clusters in AWS at my previous job. I was very excited to work on Talos because I've heard such good things and I love the idea of it being so minimal and secure. Unfortunately I don't have great things to say.

1. The (paid) support we received was terrible. We constantly got push back and support didn't really ever help us with issues.

2. We used KubeSpan, which at the time leaked the private wireguard key to the logs when debug mode was enabled. The Preshared key was also written to the logs...and the preshared key is also the cluster secret. This has since been fixed in [this PR](https://github.com/siderolabs/talos/commit/d0b50aa76)

3. We later had an issue with KubeSpan where all our worker nodes dropped one node from it's peerlist. We were using Sidero's discovery service, so we didn't have as much visibility into why/if the discovery service failed. By design the kubelet heartbeat doesn't go over KubeSpan/Wireguard, therefore the worker node reported healthy the entire time, even though no traffic inside the cluster could reach the node, which caused issues with our pods in the cluster. Sidero support wasn't helpful and we decided to just rip out KubeSpan.

4. Sidero deprecated their cluster-api and push people to use their BSL Omni (A common trend I got from support was being pushed to use their enterprise offerings) https://github.com/siderolabs/cluster-api-bootstrap-provider...

5. Recently Sidero (the company behind Talos) got acquired: https://www.siderolabs.com/blog/sidero-labs-joins-yardi . Time will tell if that is good or bad.

For all these reasons I'm not as positive about Talos anymore. I went looking for a CNCF backed project and found https://kairos.io/ , which then has their Hadron OS. I have never tested Kairos+Hadron and I don't like that it uses systemd, but it is at least a CNCF backed project. I'd feel a lot more comfortable if Sidero (Yardi?) donated Talos to the CNCF.

I still think Talos is the best option out there but I hope that changes, or I hope Sidero gets better.

There are no comments on this comment yet.